KPBS Film Critic Beth Accomando reviews "Heartbreaker"
Related Story: Review: 'Heartbreaker'
KPBS Radio Film Review: "Heartbreaker"
By Beth Accomando
Air date: September 23, 2010
A young man runs a business designed to break up relationships. That's the premise of the new French comedy "Heartbreaker." KPBS film critic Beth Accomando has this review.
HEART(ba).wav SOQ 3:50 (music out at 4:50)
(Tag:) "Heartbreaker" opens tomorrow (Friday) at Landmark's La Jolla Village Theaters. You can find more of Beth's film and DVD reviews online at K-P-B-S-dot-O-R-G-slash-cinema-junkie.
According to Alex there are three types of women…
CLIP Alex explains in French…
Those who are happy, those who are unhappy and know it, and those who are unhappy without realizing it. Alex targets the third group. He and his sister run a business in which Alex is hired out to break up relationships. So if you are a concerned father and your son-in-law turns out to be a jerk or if your best friend has just made the worst romantic decision of her life… well then you can hire Alex. He has a routine that works on any woman, in any language…
CLIP Montage of jobs.
And it always ends with a kiss and heartbreak. You see Alex shows these women the kind of perfect love they could have but then he exits the scene and collects his fee. But his latest client, a woman named Juliette, proves to be a particular challenge mainly because she seems blissfully happy with her handsome, rich, and attentive finacee. So Alex has to come up with a clever scheme to infiltrate her life.
CLIP Alex: I am the bodyguard.
Fiancee: Alex, isn't it.
Alex: Well, everything's all right?
Alex pretends Juliette's father has hired him as her bodyguard and he uses that as an excuse to be with her constantly. This also allows him to show how much they have in common… like an affinity for singing along to a George Michael song.
CLIP George Michael's song on radio
But for the first time. Alex finds a woman who doesn't immediately fall for him and that makes him fall for her. Romantic comedies are generally not my cup of tea but this French film goes down a little easier mainly because lead actor Roman Duris is so much fun to watch. He plays the role straight rather than going for the obvious laughs. But Duris finds considerable humor in the serious way Alex approaches his profession. Plus when it comes time for Alex to re-enact a scene from "Dirty Dancing," Duris proves to have some great moves on the dance floor.
Unlike most American romantic comedies, this French counterpart is less hysterical in tone and therefore feels less like a TV sitcom. This means it's driven less by gags and more by character. Take for example the supporting cast.Alex's sister Melanie and her husband Marc. They are nicely developed characters that join Alex on his missions and really get into their work. At one point, they flirt with each other over drinks but as the alter egos they've created for the job.
CLIP Flirting in French
The only problem is that Marc gets jealous of his own alter ego. The actors make the comedy work here. Julie Ferrier as Melanie has very malleable face perfect for conveying comic reactions, and Francois Damien as Marc is adept at physical comedy and hurt feelings. Together they are a delight, and make sure you stay through the end credits to catch a final gag from them. Unfotunately this trio of likable actors end up making the dull leading lady look bad. Vanessa Paradis cripples the film with her lackluster work. Her performance is so bland that we simply can't fathom how Alex can fall in love with her.
Despite Paradis, "Heartbreaker" offers a breezy trifle that arrives in theaters like a final attempt to extend the sunny mood of summer. The film goes down easy like a cool drink on a hot day but it's likely to be all but forgotten by morning.
For KPBS, I'm Beth Accomando.