Skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

Red Cliff and Ninja Assassin Reviews

November 24, 2009 5:39 p.m.

KPBS Film Critic Beth Accomando reviews Red Cliff and Ninja Assassin

Related Story: Asian Action at Theaters


This is a rush transcript created by a contractor for KPBS to improve accessibility for the deaf and hard-of-hearing. Please refer to the media file as the formal record of this interview. Opinions expressed by guests during interviews reflect the guest’s individual views and do not necessarily represent those of KPBS staff, members or its sponsors.

KPBS FM Film Review: “Red Cliff” and “Ninja Assassin”
By Beth Accomando
Air Date: November 25, 2009

This Thanksgiving holiday two very different kinds of action films square off at theaters. KPBS film critic Beth Accomando says you can choose between John Woo’s epic “Red Cliff” or the video game-like “Ninja Assassin.”

ACTION(ba).wav SOQ 3:50

(Tag:) “Red Cliff” opens Wednesday exclusively at Landmark Theaters and “Ninja Assassin” opens Wednesday throughout San Diego. For more of Beth’s reviews and interviews go to K-P-B-S-dot-O-R-G-slash-cinema-junke.

If you like action then you’ll have something to be thankful for this holiday weekend as third century Chinese armies and ninja assassins invade theaters.

CLIP Soldier: Go to infrared boys.
Rain: They’re already in the room. (SFX guns and swords)

KPBS film critic Beth Accomando will review “Red Cliff” and “Ninja Assassin” coming up next on Morning Edition.

If you are an action junkie like me than you have been waiting a long time for Hong Kong director John Woo to return to Asia to make his dream project “Red Cliff.” Inspired by actual events that took place in third century China, “Red Cliff” serves up a historical epic about how a smaller army can defeat a larger more powerful one through teamwork, innovative strategy, and sheer audacity.

This marks Woo’s first film to be shot in Mainland China and his first in decades to use a period setting. But to Woo there’s no difference in how he approaches action.

John Woo: I mean a gun battle or a battle with two swords, it still remains the same themes of friendship, love, courage, and romanticism…

“Red Cliff,” like Woo’s Hong Kong gangster films, is infused with what’s been called “heroic bloodshed,” a romanticized sense of action in which the characters, regardless of their background or situation, display heroic qualities. In “Red Cliff,” a soldier rescues a baby while fighting off a slew of enemies…


Then the generals display a prowess in the field that’s breathtaking. Only John Woo could have a man riding full tilt on a horse and have him gracefully lean over to catch a spear in midair and without missing a beat flip it over to attack his enemy. You might be surprised to discover that a major influence on Woo’s action style is MGM musicals.

John Woo: Whenever I am choreographing the action sequence I still feel I am choreographing a dancing sequence. I am so concerned about the rhythm of the action and the beauty of the body movements that it’s like a dance. So yes it still gives me a lot of influence.

Yet despite finding awe-inspiring beauty in action, Woo also creates films with strong emotional cores. His favorite themes involve honor and loyalty, but Woo is also concerned with the cost of violence especially within the context of war.

John Woo: Even though it is a war movie, it also has a pretty strong message of anti-war. I would also like to stress that in war there are no winners.

“Red Cliff” is Woo’s finest film in years. The battles are orchestrated in stunning manner and the action always reveals something about the characters. The only bad thing is that U.S. distributors didn’t think American audiences could sit through the two-part epic in it’s original near five-hour length. So what’s arriving at Landmark is a truncated one-part version of the film. This reduced version keeps much of the action intact but loses the intricacies and complex dynamics of relationships.

But there’s nothing complex about “Ninja Assassin.” It’s a totally mindless but fun action film aimed squarely at males who love gory video games. The plot – what little there is – involves a boy trained to be, well you know, a ninja assassin.

CLIP Sensei: Abandoned your parents and without a home you should have died but instead you fought and your entire life has brought you to this point, now you must prove.

Although “Ninja Assassin” is not based on an actual video game, it reveals how Hollywood is trying to tap into the huge gaming audience that made Modern Warfare a record breaking best seller. “Ninja Assassin” has Korean pop star Pain playing a renegade ninja challenging his old master and fighting off an army of assassins. As in a video game the enemy attacks in massive waves and is killed off in rapid, bloody fashion. The protagonist -- who stands in for the gamer -- has the power to heal himself so he can keep reviving to fight more ninjas.

“Ninja Assassin” doesn’t pretend to be anything more than it is – dumb violent fun. And if that’s what you’re looking for and expecting, you won’t be disappointed. But there’s no story and zero character development. The fact that there’s not much talking is actually a relief since the film is far more eloquent with its action than its dialogue, which is strained and clichéd.

CLIP Do you remember the sound she made when I stuck her?

Ouch! The action is courtesy of 87Eleven, an L.A. based stunt company. Here they deliver fast and furious action with no time to enjoy any beauty or grace as Woo does. They have obviously been influenced by Asian action films and by video games. But in this context, they don’t get to display much variety.

So as I head into the holidays, I’m thankful to see the master of heroic bloodshed back on the big screen but I’d be a lot more grateful if “Ref Cliff” were screening in its entirety and if Hollywood action films would stop ripping off Asian ones and start developing a unique style of their own.

For KPBS, I’m Beth Accomando.