skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

The Best and Worst of 2009

Single Men, Serious Men, Zombies and More

Above: Heath Ledger in his last film role in "The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus"


Aired 12/30/09

KPBS Film Critic Beth Accomando picks the best of 2009.


You can listen to my Top Ten picks or read the complete best and worst of 2009.

Every year I agonize over my ten best list because I always feel like I’m comparing apples to elephants. I mean how do you compare Nazi zombies with the slaughter of dolphins? And how do you rank a film that you can take delight in seeing dozens of times with something more artfully crafted but not really designed for repeated viewings? Aargh! It’s so hard.

"(500) Days of Summer"

Fox Searchlight

Above: "(500) Days of Summer"

Let me begin by giving kudos to a few films that revitalized their genres but didn’t quite make my top ten. In a year where “New Moon” drained the life from vampires, “Thirst” gave them new blood. “The Cove” and Burma VJ” proved that documentaries could be taut thrillers and not just talking heads. “(500) Days of Summer” gave some bite to romance flicks before copping out to cliché at the end while “The Hangover,” “Bruno,” “Zombieland,” and “In the Loop” reinvigorated comedy. And Hayao Miyazaki’s “Ponyo,” Wes Anderson’s “Fantastic Mr. Fox,” and Michel Ocelot’s “Azur and Asmar” proved that animation without CGI could be absolutely delightful.

Jason Statham returns as Chev Chelios in Crank: High Voltage


Above: Jason Statham returns as Chev Chelios in Crank: High Voltage

The three films tied for my tenth spot illustrate my quandary. There’s Terry Gilliam’s wildly inspired “The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus,” which Gilliam managed to rewrite in seamless fashion to deal with the death of Heath Ledger halfway through production and the casting of three actors (Johnny Depp, Jude Law, Colin Farrell) to finish his role. Then there’s the luminous Mexican contemplation on faith, “Silent Light.” And then there’s the crass adrenaline driven B-movie “Crank High Voltage” that I just had to highlight because it was such unabashed stupid fun and refused to follow any rules. It’s also the only film to come remotely close to capturing the feel of being in a video game.

"Pontypool," a zombie film without zombies?

IFC Films

Above: "Pontypool," a zombie film without zombies?

I am also thrilled to be able to include the subtle horror film “Pontypool,” a zombie film without zombies. Yeah you heard me right. Sounds impossible but Bruce McDonald pulls it off and reinvents the genre in ways I could have never imagined. In this zombie scenario, the infection is spread through language and words can destroy your mind. It’s amazingly effective.

Tony Leung in John Woo's "Red Cliff"

Magnolia Pictures

Above: Tony Leung in John Woo's "Red Cliff"

I debated including John Woo’s “Red Cliff” in my top ten only because it was released in the U.S. in a condensed single film rather than in its original two-part, five-hour form. But why punish Woo and his film for a bad decision made by the distributor. Woo is in top form in this historical war epic. He truly handles action better than anyone else and enriches his film with his favorite themes of honor, loyalty, and betrayal. The battles are breathtaking and it’s great to see Woo working back in Asia again.

Jeremy Renner in "The Hurt Locker"


Above: Jeremy Renner in "The Hurt Locker"

Contemporary warfare provides the backdrop for Kathryn Bigelow’s “The Hurt Locker.” Bigelow is another director with a flair for action that hasn’t had a hit in a while. Actor Jeremy Renner scores big as a bomb expert who’s an adrenaline junkie but not a gung ho warrior. “The Hurt Locker” delivers a fresh take on the war and on the modern soldier.

Majid Majidi's The Song of the Sparrows

Regent Releasing

Above: Majid Majidi's The Song of the Sparrows

And a fresh perspective on everyday life is what makes Majid Majidi’s “The Song of Sparrows” so special. This Iranian film turns simplicity into breathtaking artistry. As with his earlier films ("Baran," "Children of Heaven," "The Color of Paradise"), Majidi's latest offers a simple slice of life that ends up being about so much more.

Eli Roth and Brad Pitt administering justice "Inglourious Basterds" style

The Weinstein Company

Above: Eli Roth and Brad Pitt administering justice "Inglourious Basterds" style

Heading into the fifth slot you’ll find a distinct change in tone and style with Quentin Tarantino’s “Inglorious Basterds.” This film is just damn fun as Tarantino revels in his love of cinema and delivers a gritty war film in the tradition of Sam Fuller and Robert Aldrich. And no one delivered a better performance than Christoph Waltz as the Nazi officer that oozes polite charm and lethal effectiveness.

"A Serious Man"

Focus Features

Above: "A Serious Man"

If Tarantino specializes in audacious fun, the Coen Brothers excel at precision control. In “A Serious Man” they nail the sixties period right down to the shag carpets as they chronicle a man’s life falling apart. The film serves up one of the year’s best ensemble casts as it delivers a tale that is painfully funny and one of their darkest films yet. Every man Larry Gopnik protests early on that he hasn’t done anything and this eventually turns into an existential refrain. But in this instance, it doesn’t seem to matter what one does, things are just destined to turn out badly.

This alien just wants to go home in "District 9"

Sony Pictures

Above: This alien just wants to go home in "District 9"

One of the most exciting surprises of the year is the feature debut of Neill Blomkamp, “District 9.” This film kicks butt on “Avatar” in terms of innovation, clever scriptwriting, and putting the humanity back into science fiction. “District 9” takes familiar elements – aliens on earth, evil government/corporation conspiracy, the immigrant experience, and xenophobia – but allows us to view them from a new perspective.

Colin Firth and Julianne Moore in "A Single Man"

The Weinstein Company

Above: Colin Firth and Julianne Moore in "A Single Man"

The human element is front and center in another feature debut, Tom Ford’s “A Single Man.” As George, Colin Firth gives the year’s best lead performance as a man coping with grief and loss, and Ford’s ability to convey George’s subjective point of view is what makes this film a standout. I just saw the film for a second time and noticed even more ways that Ford conveys that subjectivity. He plays with color saturation as a means of showing how George would occasionally be brought out of his depression and experience a flood of emotion. It’s an exquisite film, inspiring in it’s artistry.

Toni Servillo (center) as Giulio Andreotti in Paolo Sorrentino's "Il Divo"

Music Box Films

Above: Toni Servillo (center) as Giulio Andreotti in Paolo Sorrentino's "Il Divo"

And finally, coming in at number one is Paolo Sorrentino’s “Il Divo,” a wildly inventive portrait of Guilio Andreotti, one of Italy's most powerful, feared and intriguing political figures. Sorrentino knows he has a fantastical tale to tell and he delivers it with all the drama, spectacle, and flamboyance of a great Italian opera.

And here’s a list of a few other bests worth highlighting.

Best performance by an actress: Tilda Swinton, “Julia”

Runners up: Hiam Abbass, “The Lemon Tree;” Ok-vin Kim, “Thirst;” Charlotte Gainsbourg, “Antichrist”

Best performance by an actor: Colin Firth, “A Single Man”

Runners up: Tom Hardy, “Bronson;” Jeremy Renner, “The Hurt Locker;” Ben Foster, “The Messenger;” Sam Rockwell, “Moon;” Sharlto Copley, “District 9,” Alfredo Castro, “Tony Manero;” Tony Servillo, “Il Divo”

Best cameo: Bill Murray playing himself in “Zombieland”

Best musical moment: Michael C. Hall lip-synching to “I Got You Under My Skin” in “Gamer”

Ken'ichi Matsuyama in his dual roles for "Detroit Metal City"


Above: Ken'ichi Matsuyama in his dual roles for "Detroit Metal City"

Best New Addition to the Film Scene: SDAFF’s Asian Extreme, which brought us “Detroit Metal City,” “Neko Raman,” “Vampire Girl vs. Frankenstein Girl,” and “Afro Samurai Resurrection.” Heck, any of those could have been on my ten best if the list were just for films that I can watch repeatedly and always get joy out of them. I can’t tell you how happy I was to see a near sell out crowd late night at a festival for Asian Extreme. Woo-hoo!

Best horror moment: A victim’s point of view as she wakes up to discover she’s being disemboweled by zombies in “Dead Snow”

Best documentary: “The Cove” and “Burma VJ”

Runners up: “Anvil,” “The Beaches of Agnes”

Best animated film: “Ponyo” and “Fantastic Mr. Fox”

Runners up: “Azur and Asmar,” “Up”

Best song: “Stu’s Song” in “The Hangover” and “We Love Violence” in “The Imaginarium of Dr. Parnassus”

Best ensemble: “A Serious Man”

Runners up: “In the Loop,” “Il Divo,” “Star Trek”

Best remake: “Star Trek”

Worst remake: “Land of the Lost,” “Friday the 13th”

Worst animated film: “A Christmas Carol”

"The Strip"

Fortress Products

Above: "The Strip"

Worst film of the year: “The Strip”

Runners up: “Nine,” “It’s Complicated”

Worst casting decision: Nicole Kidman as an Italian sex goddess in “Nine”

Worst sequel: “Terminator Salvation” and “Transformers 2”

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'DRaGZ'

DRaGZ | December 31, 2009 at 10:28 a.m. ― 7 years, 2 months ago

I'm not sure if you can really call A Christmas Carol an animated film, because it's only really animated in the sense that it uses special effects to capture a performance, and by that definition that's exactly what normal film does.

Then again, anytime CG special effects are being used in film anyway, it's pretty much animation to begin with.

Hell, let's just do away with the animation genre altogether.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'trere8'

trere8 | December 31, 2009 at 10:50 a.m. ― 7 years, 2 months ago

Great picks! I also liked Terry Crews' rendition of Pinocchio's, "I've Got No Strings" in Gamer. Golden classics at their most menacing.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'IanForbes'

IanForbes | December 31, 2009 at 11:17 p.m. ― 7 years, 2 months ago

Nicely done, Beth. Now I feel like I'm slacking since I've yet to post individual accolades like acting and such. :) And I love the picture you chose for Crank II, it really sums up what the audience should be feeling.

( | suggest removal )