skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

Roundtable Opera Bows Out; Water In Imperial Valley; Sweetwater Troubles

KPBS Roundtable

Roundtable: Opera Bows Out; Water In Imperial Valley; Sweetwater Troubles


Aired 3/21/14


Mark Sauer


Beth Accomando, KPBS News

Tony Perry, LA Times

Wendy Fry, NBC 7


San Diego Opera's Last Act

The news that the San Diego Opera will cease operations next month after the final performance of "Don Quixote" was a genuine shock to many San Diegans.

In its nearly 50 years in San Diego the opera weathered both bad and indifferent economic times but managed to stay happily afloat. In fact, it boasted 28 consecutive years of balanced budgets, including — ironically — this year.

But to the opera's board of trustees and artistic director-CEO Ian Campbell, the road forward was surely a rocky, increasingly perilous path, with bankruptcy at the end instead of a pot of gold.

The opera's operating budget of $15 million meant it was required to raise about $10 million from donations because ticket sales cover only one-third of the budget. The recent recession claimed both donors and audiences, which never returned. The opera cut costs (its budget in 2007 was some $2 million more than 2014) and shortened seasons and performances.

Further, with careful maneuvering over 10 years, the Opera spent down a $10 million bequest from Joan Kroc. (She had expected it to be gone in three.)

The loss of the San Diego Opera will be felt, of course, by those who love its music, but perhaps most by the 117 people it employs and the many local musicians and chorus members who perform.

Drought? What Drought?

The Imperial Valley may be a desert, it may even be in a state suffering from drought. But the farmers in this sparsely populated corner of California currently have all the water they need to grow the crops that feed the rest of us. Most of the crops, anyway.

The valley gets its water directly from the Colorado River, its share determined by its seniority in the 1922 Colorado River Compact.

Imperial County (population: 175,000) is entitled to some 3 million acre feet of Colorado River water, only 3 percent of which goes toward residential use. Los Angeles County (population: a whopping 19 million) gets only 1 million acre feet.

If the federal agency that manages the river imposes drought rules now or later, Nevada and Arizona would have their allocations cut before the Imperial Irrigation District. But things could change. The district was forced a decade ago to sell water to the San Diego County Metropolitan Water Authority. If they hadn't agreed to sell, the feds would have taken the water without compensation.

Since that time, Imperial Valley farmers have had to leave some acreage fallow, a situation they generally despise.

The question is, how long can the Imperial Valley hold out against the drought, the feds and calls for change to the Colorado River statute, which makes valley farmers “first in time, first in right.”

Troubles for Sweetwater, South Bay Schools

The troubles just keep coming for school districts in the South Bay.

Sweetwater Union High School District trustee Pearl Quinones, who had vowed to fight charges against her to the bitter end, entered a guilty plea to one felony and one misdemeanor count for failing to disclose gifts from contractors as far back as 2007.

Quinones is one of three current and former Sweetwater trustees facing charges in this branch of the many-tentacled, pay-to-play scandal also involving former Sweetwater superintendent Jesus Gandara and officials from Southwestern College and San Ysidro Elementary School District. In addition, it has been reported that the San Ysidro district is approaching insolvency.

As if this weren’t enough, Sweetwater Union High School district teachers authorized a strike last Friday over contributions to the district’s health plan, which the district says is an increase of $4,000 and the teachers say is a decrease of $3,000. They are working under a contract that expired in July 2013.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'Rich'

Rich | March 22, 2014 at 3:55 p.m. ― 3 years ago

Dear Roundtable, it seems odd that KPBS would have a discussion about the CA drought & Imperial Valley water without a representative of the IV Press present for the roundtable. At the very least I'd expect an interview with an Imperial Irrigation District representative. The additional interview was with a representative of the SD Water Authority. Though Tony Perry did a decent job of looking at both sides of the water issue: population served vs. ag. production, he's still a SD representative (for the LA Times) and does better on other topics. KPBS TV and radio (KQVO) serve the Imperial Valley so c'mon guys, use some IV sources in your reporting. The former morning edition used to have a Friday roundup with the editor of the IV Press. There is also a branch campus of SDSU in Calexico so there is no excuse for KPBS's blind spot in representing Imperial Valley perspectives in the news. Regards, Rich Ryan, El Centro

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'Pat Finn'

Pat Finn, KPBS Staff | March 23, 2014 at 10:15 p.m. ― 3 years ago

Thanks for your comment, and you're right. With some pre-planning, we can and should get reporters from the IV press on occasionally. The big problem is that they can't do it by phone because it's on both TV and radio, so they have to drive here. That said, Tony Perry was on because of the great piece he wrote in the Times about the history of Colorado River water rights and how that history relates to the current water situation in the Imperial Valley.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'Zwski'

Zwski | March 25, 2014 at 6:50 a.m. ― 2 years, 12 months ago

the SD "opera" had poor repertoire managing. thats why I believe they failed.

( | suggest removal )