Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations
Watch Live

Public Safety

San Diego Lifeguard Union Leader Sues City Alleging Retaliation By Fire Chief

San Diego lifeguards monitor the beach at Tourmaline Surf Park in Pacific Beach, Aug. 26, 2014.
Christopher Maue
San Diego lifeguards monitor the beach at Tourmaline Surf Park in Pacific Beach, Aug. 26, 2014.

The head of San Diego’s lifeguard union has accused the city’s fire chief of deliberately manipulating public safety data to justify expanding his budget.

In a lawsuit filed against the city Tuesday, San Diego Lifeguard Sgt. Ed Harris claimed that for more than a year Fire Chief Brian Fennessy “modified the 9-1-1 response procedures” for water-related emergencies.

San Diego Lifeguard Sgt. Ed Harris shown here as an interim city councilman in 2014.
City of San Diego
San Diego Lifeguard Sgt. Ed Harris shown here as an interim city councilman in 2014.

The lawsuit claims the change was made so that incoming calls would be sent directly to the city’s fire department instead of the city’s lifeguard division, as had been the practice for more than 30 years. The idea was to inflate the fire department’s workload so it could hire more personnel, according to the lawsuit.

Advertisement

“The changes caused confusion for dispatchers and resulted in delayed responses to water-related emergency calls,” according to the lawsuit. “One such call was a high-profile incident during which a two-year-old child drowned at Mission Bay Park.”

After that incident in March, Harris publicly alleged that a change in dispatch rules delayed a response to the drowning call by emergency workers.

Harris said Fennessy has pushed hard for firefighters to do water emergency rescues instead of lifeguards.

San Diego Lifeguard Union Leader Sues City Alleging Retaliation By Fire Chief

Harris contended that Fennessy’s motive was to inflate the fire department’s workload so he could hire more firefighters.

Harris said when he objected to Fennessy’s plan, he faced retaliation.

Advertisement

“Since December, there’s been three investigations brought against me and two of them have been cleared with no result and now there’s a third one pending,” Harris said.

He said he filed the lawsuit to stop the harassment and to get records crucial to the fire department’s investigation of him.

Harris alleged under Fennessy’s leadership, lifeguard morale and standards have slipped. KPBS reached out to Fennessy and his spokeswoman said the city does not comment on pending litigation.

San Diego Lifeguard Union Leader Sues City Alleging Retaliation By Fire Chief
Ed Harris said he was threatened with a formal reprimand and investigated three times after he was critical of Fire Chief Brian Fennessy's push to have firefighters handle water-related emergencies.

KPBS has created a public safety coverage policy to guide decisions on what stories we prioritize, as well as whose narratives we need to include to tell complete stories that best serve our audiences. This policy was shaped through months of training with the Poynter Institute and feedback from the community. You can read the full policy here.