skip to main content

Listen

Read

Watch

Schedules

Programs

Events

Give

Account

Donation Heart Ribbon

Judge Approves Convention Center Expansion

Above: Concept photo of the proposed expansion of the San Diego Convention Center.

SAN DIEGO (CNS) - A San Diego Superior Court judge gave his final blessing today to the city of San Diego's plan to finance an upcoming $520 million expansion of the downtown convention center.

Judge Ronald Prager upheld his tentative ruling, issued Monday, that says a special district formed for hotel land owners to tax themselves was "properly formed.'' The judge listened to about two hours of oral arguments Wednesday from lawyers who support and oppose the funding mechanism.

The go-ahead is one of the last hurdles the city needs to clear before the start of construction. The expansion plan still needs to go before the California Coastal Commission.

Once construction begins, work should take about 33 months, according to the city.

"I welcomed this decision. It was well-reasoned and based upon the law,'' City Attorney Jan Goldsmith said. "Should convention center opponents choose to appeal, we are confident the decision will be upheld.''

Hotels in downtown San Diego, which would benefit the most from a larger meeting facility, will charge themselves 3 percent of their room rates to help pay off debt service from construction bonds. Hotels in Mission Valley and Mission Bay will be assessed 2 percent. Outlying hotels will pay 1 percent.

The levy is expected to raise about $30 million a year. The city plans to kick in $3.5 million annually, and the Port of San Diego will add $3 million a year.

The city filed the validation lawsuit to seek clarity in what was an untested area of the law.

A group called San Diegans for Open Government and civic activist Mel Shapiro opposed the funding plan, calling it a tax that required a public election. The plan was approved in a vote of hoteliers that was weighted toward those with the most rooms.

Prager said the hotel land owners were the appropriate voters. He rejected most of the arguments of SDOG and Shapiro during Wednesday's court hearing.

The center would grow to 2.75 million square feet of floor space, with the most contiguous floor space on the West Coast at 750,000 square feet, project manager Charles Black told the City Council last year.

The city can expect an extra 25 major trade shows per year, bringing 250,000 visitors and their wallets to San Diego, Black said.

He said the annual economic impact of expansion on the region would be $689 million, including a direct bump of $76 million in spending at restaurants and retail outlets. The city will receive an additional $13.5 million in tax revenues, he said.

Area tourism officials say organizers of the biggest trade shows have been bypassing San Diego because the local facility is not big enough. Comic-Con International, which originated in San Diego, had been courted by other cities but chose to remain when an expansion was promised.

Comments

Avatar for user 'DonWood'

DonWood | March 14, 2013 at 6:04 p.m. ― 1 year, 6 months ago

This ruling undercuts Prop 13 and Prop 26 protections against new taxation without a citywide vote. If upheld, it will unleash new municipal taxes accross the state as special interest groups hold closed elections to increase taxes on their customers, then bribe elected officials to go along with it. Presumably, Judge Prager expects to get big contributions from hotel owners for his reelection campaign, but if voters find out that he's the judge who tried to repeal Props 13 and 26, he won't be able to hide. Maybe he can get a job with the city attorney's office or at one of the big hotels.

( | suggest removal )