Source May Have Misled Media About Key Benghazi Email
Wednesday, May 15, 2013
In the reporting about multiple revisions made by the Obama administration to "talking points" concerning last September's deadly attack on Americans in Benghazi, Libya, one of the hottest stories in recent weeks was this one from ABC News on Friday:
In it, ABC's Jonathan Karl said that "ABC News has obtained 12 different versions of the talking points" and that "White House emails reviewed by ABC News suggest the edits were made with extensive input from the State Department."
Karl's account includes this important passage:
"In an email dated 9/14/12 at 9:34 p.m. -- three days after the attack and two days before Ambassador Rice appeared on the Sunday shows -- Deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes wrote an email saying the State Department's concerns needed to be addressed. 'We must make sure that the talking points reflect all agency equities, including those of the State Department, and we don't want to undermine the FBI investigation,' [Karl quoted Rhodes as saying]. We thus will work through the talking points tomorrow morning at the Deputies Committee meeting.' "
Karl added that the next day the State Department's concerns were addressed: "The CIA drafted the final version of the talking points," he reported, "deleting all references to al-Qaida and to the security warnings in Benghazi prior to the attack."
The implication was that the White House, thanks in part to the email from Rhodes, had weighed in on the side of the State Department to downplay any al-Qaida connection to the attack that killed the U.S. ambassador and three other Americans. Another key implication: That ABC News had seen the email.
Tuesday, CNN's Jake Tapper landed with this:
"CNN has obtained an e-mail sent by a top aide to President Barack Obama about White House reaction to the deadly attack last September 11 on the U.S. diplomatic compound in Benghazi, Libya, that apparently differs from how sources characterized it to two different media organizations.
"The actual e-mail from then-Deputy National Security Adviser for Strategic Communications Ben Rhodes appears to show that whomever leaked it did so in a way that made it appear that the White House was primarily concerned with the State Department's desire to remove references and warnings about specific terrorist groups so as to not bring criticism to the department."
Tapper posted the email here. It appears to show Rhodes wrote that: "We need to resolve this in a way that respects all the relevant equities, particularly the investigation." He adds that "a ton of wrong information" was being distributed and that "insofar as we have firmed up assessments that don't compromise intel or the investigation, we need to have the capability to correct the record."
There's no mention of the State Department in the email Tapper obtained. The source who told Karl otherwise, "seemingly invented the notion that Rhodes wanted the concerns of the State Department specifically addressed," Tapper reports.
The White House, as The Hill writes, is accusing congressional Republicans of being behind the version of events that Karl was given.
As for Karl, he's still saying he "obtained" the email. But he also says he was "quoting verbatim a source who reviewed the original documents and shared detailed notes. ... The source was not permitted to make copies of the original e-mails. The White House has refused multiple requests -- from journalists, including myself, and from Republican leaders in Congress -- to release the full e-mail exchanges."
Merriam-Webster's definition of the word obtain: "To gain or get (something) usually by effort."
Karl adds that:
"I asked my original source [Tuesday] to explain the different wording on the Ben Rhodes e-mail, and the fact that the words 'State Department' were not included in the e-mail provided to CNN's Tapper.
"This was my source's response, via e-mail: 'WH reply was after a long chain of email about State Dept concerns. So when WH emailer says, take into account all equities, he is talking about the State equities, since that is what the email chain was about.' "
Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit www.npr.org.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.