Eyes Look To Carlsbad’s Desalination Plant
Monday, July 27, 2015
Many people are watching the Carlsbad desalination plant that could begin delivering drinking water by fall. And how the plant performs may affect how other desalination projects are viewed.
San Diego County water officials will soon find out if their billion-dollar wager on ocean water desalination will pay off.
Crews are putting the finishing touches on a Carlsbad plant that could start producing drinking water this fall, and there are a lot of people watching to see how it works out.
Much of the remaining work is focused on finishing the outside walls, adding parking areas and landscaping.
"The bulk of the construction is now behind us and we're in the final stages of proving out the facilities and getting it ready for operation later this fall," said Peter MacLaggan, vice president of Poseidon Water, the company building the facility.
MacLaggan is a tireless advocate for seawater desalination as a drought-proof water supply.
"It's always available, regardless of whether it snows in the Sierras or the Rocky Mountains. Or whether in rains in San Diego," MacGlaggan said.
The plant is designed to produce 50 million gallons of drinking water a day, which is enough to fill an Olympic-size swimming pool every 18 minutes. The new water will represent up to 10 percent of the San Diego region's supply.
"Everybody's watching what happens here in Carlsbad to gauge how they're going to proceed with their local plans," MacGlaggan said. "The success of this plant will demonstrate the viability of this technology as a future municipal water supply for other communities."
There are 17 desalination projects in various stages of development on the West Coast. One is a Poseidon proposal in Huntington Beach. Another is an attempt to revive a desalination facility in Santa Barbara. A bumpy start here might influence the course those other projects take.
"It's hard to say what the long-term impacts are going to be, but people are looking (at) this plant to try to better understand what the opportunities and challenges are for California," said Heather Cooley of the Pacific Institute.
There are a lot of things for communities to consider when developing a water source that's twice as expensive as imported water, Cooley said.
"It'll depend on how low demand is and whether there's cheaper efficiency options available," Cooley said. "It'll depend on what the other supply options might be in the other area."
Critics are not ready to give up the fight, even though the plant is about to open.
Surfrider San Diego's Julia Chunn-Heer is not convinced this is the right time for large-scale desalination.
"Desalination shouldn't be the first thing that we're turning to solve our water crisis," Chunn-Heer said. "It's probably part of the equation, but there's a lot more that we can do in terms of conservation and water use, before we turn, before we get there."
Chunn-Heer said taking salt out of ocean water uses too much energy and leaves a huge carbon footprint. Plant officials plan to spend roughly $200,000 a year to buy carbon credits to offset greenhouse gas impacts created by the power used to filter water.
But there are other environmental impacts. Pulling water into the plant and discharging briny wastewater offshore puts marine life at risk.
"Our problem here is that it's not being done in a very sophisticated way," Chunn-Heer said. "They're just drawing in additional ocean water with additional marine life impacts to dilute the brine before they send it out."
State officials have already rewritten the desalination rulebook in part because of concern over the environmental impact of the Carlsbad plant. New facilities seeking a permit in California should have underground intake pipes and more sophisticated outfalls.
The Cost of Water
Metropolitan Water District: $923 per acre foot in 2015 for Tier 1 treated water
Imperial Irrigation District: about $810 per acre foot in 2015 for transferred Colorado River water
Carlsbad Desalination Plant: $1,915 to $2,140 per acre-foot
Source: San Diego County Water Authority
A 10-mile long, 56-inch pipe will carry the desalinated water across the northern part of the county to the San Diego County Water Authority's aqueduct in San Marcos. The pipeline is a critical artery that will feed the region's effort to become water independent.
But that water independence comes with a price. Desalinated water costs significantly more than imported water, but many county residents are willing to pay.
"Over 68 percent of the people polled said they'd be willing to pay something more for desalination," said Bob Yamada of the San Diego County Water Authority.
The cost of building the plant and buying the water is being paid by each water user in the county. They pay even if they don't get any of the desalinated water, Yamada said.
"The $5 a month is really a small price to pay for that additional reliability that we're going to receive by having this drought proof supply in our portfolio," Yamada said.
The desalinated water is currently about twice as expensive as imported water, but the authority projects that'll change over time.
County water managers said they locked in the cost of desalinated water for the next 30 years, while the cost of imported water is widely expected to increase over time.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.