Protests Against Planned Parenthood Rouse Dueling Rallies Nationwide
Saturday, February 11, 2017
Updated at 9:10 a.m. ET Sunday
Anti-abortion rights protesters gathered outside Planned Parenthood clinics across the country Saturday, in a series of rallies calling on politicians to end federal funding for the century-old organization. The activists planned to picket outside roughly 200 Planned Parenthood clinics — but at many of those locations, counterprotesters were there to meet them.
The group #ProtestPP, which organized the rallies, says demonstrations have been planned in at least 45 states, according to ABC News. From Detroit to Los Angeles, from St. Louis to St. Paul, The Associated Press reports that protesters have gathered with signs reading "Pray to End Abortion" and "Defend Life."
"Why should tax dollars be given to somewhere where they're doing killings of babies," anti-abortion demonstrator Marisol Pfaff asked St. Louis Public Radio's Camille Philips. Pfaff and scores of other protesters gathered Saturday outside the only clinic in Missouri that provides abortions.
Planned Parenthood — which provides a wide range of health care services for women, including abortion — receives more than $500 million a year from the federal government, about 75 percent of which comes from Medicaid.
According to Planned Parenthood, about 3 percent of the services it provided in 2014 were abortion-related. The group says the vast bulk of its services instead go toward contraception and the prevention and treatment of sexually transmitted diseases. It also provides cancer screenings and other women's services.
That's why Sharon Caldwell and a large group of other counterprotesters came out to the St. Louis clinic to rebut the claims of the anti-abortion rally Saturday. Caldwell tells Phillips the organization provided invaluable help for her after she was raped.
"They were the only people who cared," Caldwell says. "They were just like, 'A terrible thing happened. Here's how we support you.' "
The dueling rallies in St. Louis offer just a microcosm of the flurry of protests and counterprotests in cities across the U.S.
In St. Paul, Minn., The Minneapolis Star-Tribune describes a scene in which thousands of protesters and counterprotesters faced each other on the same pavement just a dozen feet apart, held back by parallel crowd barriers. The Planned Parenthood supporters — who far outnumbered their anti-abortion counterparts, according to the paper — shouted chants of "Defund Pence" and "Tax the church!"
Meanwhile, the balance was reversed outside a Denver clinic, where abortion rights opponents outnumbered the counterdemonstrators. Colorado Public Radio's Sam Brasch reports that Planned Parenthood officials actually asked supporters to stay away, fearing conflict would only make patients even feel more unwelcome. So instead, those supporters took their demonstrations downtown, where they had a large rally outside Colorado Sen. Cory Gardner's office.
Leslie Hanks, an anti-abortion demonstrator in Denver, told Brasch he hopes President Trump "does the right thing and I hope that Planned Parenthood is defunded, but that's the very least that should happen."
Anti-abortion activists have been re-energized with a new, much more sympathetic administration having moved into the White House. Vice President Mike Pence addressed the annual March for Life last month — a historic first in the major anti-abortion rally's decades-long history — and President Trump has blocked U.S. aid money from supporting groups that provide or "promote" abortion in other countries.
Still, Planned Parenthood supporters remain undeterred.
"All across the country, Planned Parenthood supporters are taking it upon themselves to organize in their communities on their own," Kelley Robinson,of Planned Parenthood Action Fund Support, said in a statement.
"Saturday, and every day, Planned Parenthood advocates and activists show that they refuse to be intimidated and they won't back down."
Clarification: This post has been updated to reflect a rally by Planned Parenthood supporters in downtown Denver.
Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.