Skip to main content

Clergy Abuse Victims Caution Against Accepting Church Settlements

A press conference to discuss the limitations and risks to victims of the new...

Photo by Andi Dukleth

Above: A press conference to discuss the limitations and risks to victims of the new “Victims Compensation Fund” announced by six California Catholic Dioceses, May 16, 2019.

Victims of sexual abuse by Catholic priests cautioned Thursday against accepting a church-sponsored program to financially compensate them.

At a news conference, several victims gathered with their lawyer and said the program does not hold the church accountable. The victims sat at a table with a banner featuring pictures of young victims and the words “stolen souls.”

One victim named Dede said she wanted people to understand the pain victims suffer at the hands of clergy.

“Do you know what it feels like to be terrorized, tormented, abused and knowing that you can’t do anything about it, that nobody believes and nobody’s gonna care?” she said.

RELATED: San Diego Catholic Diocese Adds 8 Priests To List Of Sexual Predators

Six Roman Catholic dioceses in California announced the compensation fund this week. It offers payouts to victims of abuse, with no statute of limitations, and it will be administered independently of the church.

But Irwin Zalkin, a lawyer for abuse victims, called the program a "ploy" because victims would have to agree never to sue a diocese over the abuse.

“That’s not reconciliation, that’s not recognition, that’s not vindication for the victims,” Zalkin said.

Sexual abuse victim Esther Hatfield Miller said waiving the right to sue would not allow victims to expose cover-ups perpetrated by the clergy.

RELATED: San Diego Catholic Diocese Holds Listening Sessions On Clergy Sex Abuse

"We would be unable to enforce accountability,” she said.

Aida Bustos of the Roman Catholic Diocese of San Diego said the compensation fund is the church's way of trying to right past wrongs.

“We recognize our failures, and through this program, we hope to begin the process for anyone who has been sexually abused by a priest as a minor and to get the redress that they deserve,” Bustos said.

The program is being administered by Ken Feinberg, an independent mediator who has also been in charge of the fund for 9/11 victims. It is expected to go into effect within the next couple of months.

San Diego News Matters podcast branding

In today's San Diego News Matters podcast: Victims of sexual abuse by Catholic priests have cautioned against accepting a church-sponsored program to financially compensate them. Also in the show: While President Trump pushes Congress to create a new military branch called the Space Force, the Pentagon is about to choose a permanent home for its existing Space Command. And to help address the flow of migrants at the U.S.-Mexico border, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security is tapping its partner agencies — including the TSA.

Aired: May 17, 2019 | Transcript

Victims of sexual abuse by Catholic priests have cautioned against accepting a church-sponsored program to financially compensate them. Six Roman Catholic dioceses in California announced the compensation fund this week.

You can hear this story and other local news every morning by subscribing to San Diego News Matters, KPBS’ daily news podcast. Subscribe via iTunes, Google Play or your favorite podcatcher.

Want more KPBS news?
Find us on Twitter and Facebook, or sign up for our newsletters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.