skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

Imperial Valley Tribes Oppose Sunrise Powerlink


Aired 1/5/11

On the eve of his departure from office, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger applauded one of his signature projects: The Sunrise Powerlink. The massive energy transmission line has garnered many opponents, among them Native American tribes.

Guests at the Sunrise Powerlink groundbreaking ceremony on December 9, 2010, ...
Enlarge this image

Above: Guests at the Sunrise Powerlink groundbreaking ceremony on December 9, 2010, wait for Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger to arrive in Boulevard, CA.

— On a sunny, warm day in the Imperial Valley desert, hundreds of energy executives and state officials waited for the governor to show up at the Powerlink headquarters in Boulevard, California.

Schwarzenegger appeared 20 minutes late, glowing with pride over the Sunrise Powerlink - which he sees as one of his top achievements in public office.

"This is why it is important," said Schwarzenegger, linking the power line project to his green-energy agenda for the state. "The Sunrise Powerlink will carry 1,000 megawatts of clean energy to San Diego; enough power to power 650,000 homes."

But outside of the gate, dozens of protesters booed the project and its promise of green energy. They held signs criticizing San Diego Gas & Electric and its parent company, Sempra Energy.

A few feet away, David Elliott of the Manzanita band of the Kumeyaay Nation spoke at a makeshift podium. Elliott opposes the 117-mile, 500-kilovolt mega project, which is slated to circumvent delicate desert and forest terrain to bring energy to San Diego. Most of that land, he insists, is peppered with ancient burial grounds and artifacts.

"My main concern is the cultural burials that are out there," says Elliott, referring to the entire Imperial Valley region. "We've been asked to survey thousands of acres. Where's the footprint for the proposed towers or lines or roads? All these things that they're going to put out here for the line? When we ask that question, they say, I don't know."

The "they" that Elliott referred to is SDG&E and Sempra, along with other subcontractors who have been surveying the land for over five years and applying for permits from the Bureau of Land Management and the U.S. Forestry Service.

The land that will be crisscrossed by the Powerlink is culturally and spiritually significant to other tribes such as the Cocopah, Quechan, Mojave and Hulapai. The area is also home to the Golden Eagle and the endangered Bighorn Sheep, and sensitive desert habitat.

David Elliott, a member of the the Manzanita branch of the Kumayaay Tribe in ...
Enlarge this image

Above: David Elliott, a member of the the Manzanita branch of the Kumayaay Tribe in Southeastern California, speaks to the protesters outside the Sunrise Powerlink construction site.

"As far as this being green energy, I don't see that at all," says Elliott. "The turbines, they cause noise problems, disrupt the animals, visual blight in this pristine back country, they come apart from the high winds. And of course, all these wind companies, and solar companies, and geothermal companies have sprung up because SDG&E is going to put a line through this area."

No doubt there's an energy development explosion going on these days in the Imperial Valley. Dozens of projects have popped up throughout the desert, promising jobs and green energy for Southern California and even neighboring Arizona.

Art Larson, a spokesperson with SDG&E, says the criticism is misguided and adds that the Powerlink is following all the rules.

"The licensing and approval project for the Sunrise Powerlink was the most comprehensive ever completed on a power line in California history," he says. "It included five years of testimony, hearings, public meetings, formal environmental review, and proposed alternative decisions on the project."

Bill Powers is a San Diego-based environmental engineer. He believes San Diego could generate power on rooftops - in its own backyard.

"That same technology can just as easily be put on rooftops and in parking lots right where it's used," says Powers. "And you don't need 400 miles of transmission to get it there."

Powers has challenged the project on the grounds that it harms the tribes in the area, destroys an important ecosystem, and gives too much power, literally, to investor owned utilities.

"These projects are more expensive, more resource intensive," he says. "And yet the U.S. government is throwing billions of dollars that we do not have at obsolete technology that is doing permanent damage to pristine areas of the desert: it is the perfect storm."

That storm has been brewing for years. But until very recently, the concerns of Native American tribes from the Imperial Valley were overshadowed by the purely environmental opposition to the Sunrise Powerlink.

Just days before the groundbreaking in Boulevard, President Barack Obama settled an historic lawsuit filed by various Native American tribes 15 years ago - a settlement on royalties for oil, gas, grazing and timber rights. To David Elliott, that settlement was largely symbolic.

Wind power farms have been popping along the old power line throughout the Im...
Enlarge this image

Above: Wind power farms have been popping along the old power line throughout the Imperial Valley in Eastern San Diego County over the last 5 years.

"All the resources that have been extracted from the Native American lands over the hundreds of years - there's no amount of money that the government can give those people, our people, or certain individuals would ever be able to repay what they've taken out," says Elliott. "And you look at the amount of time that it's taken to even come to this point."

But looking ahead, many tribal members throughout the Imperial Valley see legal action as the only way left to challenge the Powerlink.

A Federal judge recently granted a request by the Quechan Tribe to stop work temporarily on a solar-energy project connected to the power line. The injunction represents an important precedent to tribal lawsuits over land management in the region.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'stef'

stef | January 5, 2011 at 7:26 a.m. ― 6 years, 1 month ago

Fire fighters can not fight under these power lines. Aircraft can not drop fire retardent or water on these power lines. Several of our closest resevors can not be used to refill helocopters because they will have power lines over them. People lost lives and homes in 03 and 07. The power lines will be going though these same areas. Think this is only an east county problem?Scripts Ranch knows that fire does not stop at borders. Green energy also means little to no transportation costs. I think the potential to lose more lives and homes for SDG&E and Sempra's profit is to high of a cost.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'ScamDiego'

ScamDiego | January 5, 2011 at 10:13 a.m. ― 6 years, 1 month ago

I will echo the comment above. The only thing green about the Sunrise Powerlink is the money SDG&E/Sempra will be making by sending energy produced by fossil fuel over the line.

SDG&E had the chance to back up its claims that green energy would travel on the line when the CPUC Commissioner assigned to the Sunrise proceeding made that a condition of the line's approval. Rather than backup its green energy claims, SDG&E settled things the Big Oil way. Sempra called in a chit with the same governor whose ballot initiatives Sempra had previously bankrolled. Lo and behold, the Gov directed his appointees to the CPUC to overrule the assigned commissioner, two administrative law judges and the project's environmental document. Shameful.

Sunrise was BOUGHT, not approved. Anyone who takes the time to read the "Fire and Fuels Reduction" section of the project's environmental report would never, ever ethically or morally approve this line. It's a firestorm waiting to happen. Do not post here until you read this document:

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'brixsy'

brixsy | January 5, 2011 at 10:14 a.m. ― 6 years, 1 month ago

This project is unnecessary, it could easily have been built along a corridor that already exists. Oh, of course, we can't let that happen, because it would cost SDGE a little bit more... The capacity for problems with this line is huge, many fires have been started because of SDGEs transmission lines already.

In order to protect nature and the old way of life, one has to fight tooth and nail against the unscrupuled business interests. Do they stand for anything? How can one tear apart nature and not feel anything? We need to stop believing that money is happiness, so many people work just to buy unnecessary things instead of going outside, spending time with their families. A strong Depression might actually do us good, it might break the illusion and the money-lust trance that many of us are in.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'arttow'

arttow | January 6, 2011 at 1:23 p.m. ― 6 years, 1 month ago

The commenters above are expressing emotion not fact. This has been the most excessively studied and litigated transmission line the state has ever seen. These johnny-come-latelys were too lazy to participate in the siting process and now just come up with attacks that have no factual basis.

Here is the link the the California Independent System Operator:

Look at the interconnection queue and see how may renewable projects with connect at IV substation and will be dependent on Sunrise Powerlink.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'ahas'

ahas | April 22, 2011 at 1:23 p.m. ― 5 years, 10 months ago

The expression of emotion is based on facts which affect the regions people. There's been a misrepresentation of facts regarding the issue, as a result people express their concerns by speaking out.

The "johnny-come-latelys" is not accurate--the Powerlink oppositional movement over Sunrise Powerlink started in the 1980's. This phase orientated project is a concern for many people, and its good to see the people engaged in this collective movement.l For the people; maybe younger generations, new-residents to San Diego, people just hearing about the issue/project and feel concerned- it's NEVER TOO LATE TO CARE....

I'm glad the issues surrounding local Tribal concerns is being engaged--- as one of many "stakeholder's," and together there's a common goal.. Everything to gain our Beautiful land...Beautiful land--sage, oaks, eagles, and sacred site protection from the ground-up. A community standing together for a common goal..

“The accomplice to the crime of corruption is frequently our own indifference”

Bess Myerson quotes

( | suggest removal )