Assemblywoman Lori Saldana and retired law professor Robert Simmons debated the merits of the proposed Bajagua border sewage treatment plant Tuesday. The San Diego Bar Association sponsored the event for a group of environmental attorneys. KPBS reporter Amy Isackson has more.
Bajagua is a proposal by two San Diego businessmen to build a $200 million sewage plant in Tijuana. Bajagua supporters say it will purify Tijuana's sewage to comply with the United States' Clean Water Act. The court has ordered U.S. federal officials to comply by fall 2008.
Longtime Bajagua critic, Assemblywoman Saldana says the project is poorly engineered and does not address Tijuana's runoff.
Saldana: "It will necessitate increased costs to pump that sewage uphill 12 miles away; increase the risk of sewage spills; it will increase the flow out the outfall that is already contributing to water pollution."
But proponent, Robert Simmons, says Bajagua will not only bring Tijuana's sewage outfall up to federal standards it will also help solve Tijuana's water shortage.
Simmons: "This plant will make it possible to recycle for reuse increasing volumes of water that will be applied to eastern Tijuana uses, commercial, industrial, park."
Both Saldana and Simmons have been environmental advocates for years. The Bajagua project has sharply divided the environmental community. Amy Isackson, KPBS news.