Skip to main content

San Diego Board Of Supervisors Appoints Summer Stephan As Interim District Attorney

The San Diego County Board of Supervisors is shown in this photo, Jan. 10, 20...

Photo by Katie Schoolov

Above: The San Diego County Board of Supervisors is shown in this photo, Jan. 10, 2017.

UPDATE: 6:05 p.m., June 20, 2017

San Diego Board Of Supervisors Appoints Summer Stephan As Interim District Attorney

GUEST:

Summer Stephan, chief deputy district attorney, San Diego County

Transcript

The Board of Supervisors Tuesday appointed veteran prosecutor Summer Stephan as San Diego County's interim top prosecutor to succeed Bonnie Dumanis, who is retiring.

Stephan is the chief deputy district attorney, and has gained numerous endorsements for the permanent job when elections are held next year. She's served 28 years.

She was appointed as interim D.A. on a 4-1 vote, with Supervisor Kristin Gaspar dissenting. Others who applied for the job were Adam Gordon, a former prosecutor who now practices in business litigation and white-collar defense and retired prosecutor Greg Walden.

Dumanis, who is in her fourth term, plans to step down on July 7 and mull over a run for the District 4 supervisor's seat next year. She endorsed Stephan to be her successor.

"What I would ask you to look at is not just my internal leadership and the absolute trust that the troops have put in me, wanting me to lead them at this time and in the future," Stephan said in her opening statement to the board. "It's the fact that my leadership also extends to law enforcement and it extends to the community that we serve. I'm a trusted leader inside and outside the office."

RELATED: San Diego District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis To Step Down In July

Photo caption: Summer Stephan, who currently works as San Diego's chief deputy district atto...

Summer Stephan, who currently works as San Diego's chief deputy district attorney., is shown in this undated photo.

Opponents, however, contended that appointing Stephan would give her an unfair advantage when elections for a full term are held. Both Gordon and Walden said they would not be candidates for the permanent job.

Christie Hill, senior policy strategist for the local chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, pushed for the board of supervisors to choose an interim DA applicant who had pledged not to run for the position in next year's campaign.

"Our DA is the region's most prominent and powerful law enforcement officer," Hill said. "Because many voters are unfamiliar with these races and the candidates, incumbency is an incredibly powerful influence on election results. County voters have the right to democratically elect DA. The board of supervisors should honor democratic process and not give candidate the advantage of incumbency heading into next year's election."

Supervisor Dianne Jacob told Stephan after voting for her appointment: "In my opinion, without question, you are the best qualified and you will effectively lead the department on day one."

Opposition also came from the parents of Stephanie Crowe, a 12-year-old girl killed in her Escondido bedroom 19 years ago.

"My husband, Steve, and son, Michael, are at home. My daughter, Stephanie, is in a grave," Cheryl Crowe said.

"She was murdered, and the killer got away with it," she said in sometimes tearful comments. "It would have been a lot different if Summer Stephan had not been assigned to the case."

Crowe said Stephan spent a page and a half of her application defending her handling of the case and writing that it showed how compassionate, ethical and competent she was. "In truth, she was mean, unethical and incompetent," Crowe said.

Stephan was the second prosecutor on the troubled case, taking over when Stephanie's brother and two of the boy's friends were charged with her murder. The teens were later exonerated and a homeless man found with her blood on his sweatshirt was eventually found guilty. His conviction was overturned on appeal, however.

The process to hire the county's chief prosecutor originally called for interviews to be held today, with the field being winnowed to three and an appointment made next week. But with just three applicants and the first round of voting going strongly in Stephan's favor, the supervisors agreed to go ahead and make the appointment.

Want more KPBS news?
Find us on Twitter and Facebook, or sign up for our newsletters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.