Skip to main content

LATEST UPDATES: Tracking COVID-19 | Racial Justice | Election 2020

San Diego Researchers Question Ethics Of Chinese Scientist Who Claims To Have Genetically Modified Babies

He Jiankui, a Chinese researcher, speaks during the Human Genome Editing Conf...

Credit: Associated Press

Above: He Jiankui, a Chinese researcher, speaks during the Human Genome Editing Conference in Hong Kong, Wednesday, Nov. 28, 2018.

He Juankui from the Southern University of Science and Technology in China said this week he is the first to successfully create a genetically modified baby — but he supplied no evidence of his claim.

"At this point we have somebody releasing information on YouTube and maybe announcing something at a conference," said Michael Kalichman who is director of UC San Diego's Research Ethics Program. "That’s not evidence, that’s not science."

So why have so many news outlets picked up the story?

"I think the answer is because it's touching on a topic that is so exciting — so tantalizing to everyone," Kalichman said. "The idea that we can manipulate the genes of a future human being."

RELATED: Study Finds Public Pushing Back On Genetically Modified Mosquitoes

The China-based scientist claims he did "gene surgery" on human embryos to protect them from HIV. He said there were seven couples involved in the research, all of the men were HIV positive and the women were not. After claims about twins being born without HIV made headlines, the university he worked at put out a scathing statement. The Southern University of Science and Technology said it was shocked this might have happened and He had been on leave from the school since February. The university also said it was unaware of the research and, "utilizing CRISPR/Cas9 to edit human embryos has seriously violated academic ethics and codes of conduct."

The university has promised to investigate the reported incident.

"He violated just about every standard of research ethics that there is," said Mary Devereaux who is assistant director of UC San Diego's Research and Ethics Program. "He did not disclose to his research institution he was doing this and it was not disclosed to the scientific community."

The scientist said the twins were born a few weeks ago and are healthy, but Devereaux disagrees with that early assessment.

"He’s in no position to say that these children are as healthy as any other children," she said. "We won’t know perhaps for years whether the gene tampering he did, although it was on a single gene that we know, has any off-target effects."

At a genome conference in China this week, He said he hopes to monitor the newborns for the next 18 years and then into adult life.

"These were children who were not in any sense able to be asked themselves," Devereaux said. "Their parents were asked to sign something to allow them to be experimented on this way — but basically I think this was a violation of human rights."

He’s claims have not been peer-reviewed and published, although the scientist said he is now going through that process.

"We have clear standards and practices in place in order to make research both extremely rigorous and extremely safe," Devereaux said.

There are still many questions about the informed consent process, or what the parents who signed up for this research really knew what they were getting into.

"Who reviewed this project and decided that the risks are sufficiently small and the potential benefits are worth going ahead?" Kalichman said. "Who decided that the process was one in which you could truly get informed consent from the parents?"

He has said the research was discussed with other scientists and doctors but has not provided specifics.

"From the perspective of science it’s unproven," Kalichman said. "So the patient is choosing something that is not proven to be safe, not proven to be effective."

Reported by Kris Arciaga

The scientist, He Jiankui, who claims to be the first to successfully genetically alter twins in China, said his work has been submitted to a scientific journal, but many in the scientific community have concerns about his process.


San Diego News Matters podcast branding

KPBS' daily news podcast covering local politics, education, health, environment, the border and more. New episodes are ready weekday mornings so you can listen on your morning commute.

  • Need help keeping up with the news that matters most? Get the day's top news — ranging from local to international — straight to your inbox each weekday morning.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Photo of Matt Hoffman

Matt Hoffman
General Assignment Reporter

opening quote marksclosing quote marksI am a general assignment reporter for KPBS. In addition to covering the latest news and issues that are relevant to the San Diego community, I like to dig deeper to find the voices and perspectives that other media often miss.

Want more KPBS news?
Find us on Twitter and Facebook, or sign up for our newsletters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.