Skip to main content

LATEST UPDATES: Tracking COVID-19 | Vaccines | Racial Injustice

Sheriff’s Department Releases Unedited Video Of Deputy Allegedly Overdosing On Fentanyl

Sheriff's deputy trainee David Faiivae being given naloxone after being expos...

Credit: San Diego County Sheriff’s Department

Above: Sheriff's deputy trainee David Faiivae being given naloxone after being exposed to Fentanyl on July 3, 2021.

The video released last week was dramatic.

After packaging up some fentanyl taken from a suspect’s vehicle, Deputy David Faiivae suddenly stiffened and fell back. Almost immediately, his training officer, Deputy Scott Crane administered naloxone - given to people who have overdosed on opioids.

RELATED: San Diego Sheriff’s Fentanyl Video Alarms Medical Experts

Listen to this story by John Carroll.

The blowback came within hours. Medical professionals across the country said what the video showed was not an example of overdosing on fentanyl. Many lashed out at the Sheriff’s Department for releasing a video many said mis-portrayed a situation that plays out with deadly consequences across the country every day.

KPBS talked to Dr. Carla Marienfeld, Director of UC San Diego's Addiction Recovery & Treatment Program about what the video shows and what it doesn't.

“I think it’s helpful to release the full version so that people can see as much as you can see from a body cam," she said.

Marienfeld had not seen the unedited version when KPBS interviewed her Friday afternoon.

RELATED: San Diego Sheriff Releases Details On Disputed Fentanyl Video, But Questions Remain

But with what she has seen, she said doesn’t feel comfortable describing what happened to Deputy David Faiivae as an overdose.

Marienfeld said she’s more concerned about the unintended message the videos, edited or unedited, could send.

“The most important message is that people shouldn’t be afraid of incidental exposure to fentanyl in a limited way like this to where they would not act to help someone who might be overdosing," she said.

One thing that is new from the unedited version comes when Deputy Faiivae is answering questions from a paramedic.

RELATED: San Diego Saw Sharp Increase In Fentanyl Deaths Throughout Pandemic Lockdowns

The paramedic is questioning Faiivae to determine if he's fully conscious and aware of what's going on.

“Any medical history that you know about?” the paramedic asks.

“Probably the sixth or seventh time I’ve fallen on my head," responded Faiivae.

That leads to an obvious question as to whether Deputy Faiivae has a history of fainting, and if that’s what happened here.

Dr. Marienfeld said that it's hard to tell. “I think that you want to take into consideration the fact that the patient may have had previous head injuries and whether or not some of what he was presenting with currently was related to him hitting his head in any way," she said.

Reported by John Carroll

Then there’s the question of a toxicology test. The Sheriff’s Department now says one was not done at the hospital. Dr. Marienfeld said that’s not unusual.

“In the emergency room, you’re trying to be as efficient as possible and helping somebody... In that situation where the story was consistent with a fentanyl exposure... it wouldn’t necessarily make sense to check to see if there was fentanyl in his system, particularly if the story you heard as the physician was that the patient responded to naloxone.”

KPBS reached out to the Sheriff’s Department for clarification, but in an email, they said they weren’t doing any interviews on the subject - leaving this story kind of how it started, with way more questions than answers.


San Diego News Now podcast branding

San Diego news; when you want it, where you want it. Get local stories on politics, education, health, environment, the border and more. New episodes are ready weekday mornings. Hosted by Anica Colbert and produced by KPBS, San Diego and the Imperial County's NPR and PBS station.

  • Need help keeping up with the news that matters most? Get the day's top news — ranging from local to international — straight to your inbox each weekday morning.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

John Carroll
General Assignment Reporter & Anchor

opening quote marksclosing quote marksI'm a general assignment reporter and Saturday morning radio anchor for KPBS. I love coming up with story ideas that aren't being covered elsewhere, but I'm also ready to cover the breaking news of the day. In addition, I bring you the local news headlines on Saturday mornings during NPR's Weekend Edition.

Want more KPBS news?
Find us on Twitter and Facebook, or sign up for our newsletters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.