Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
KPBS Midday Edition

San Diego Unveils Affordable Housing Plan

City officials unveil their multi-point plant to make more affordable housing available in the city, June 21, 2017.
Erik Anderson
City officials unveil their multi-point plant to make more affordable housing available in the city, June 21, 2017.
San Diego Unveils Affordable Housing Plan
San Diego Unveils Affordable Housing Plan GUESTS: Andrew Bowen, metro reporter, KPBS Lynn Reaser, chief economist, Point Loma Nazarene University

Mayor Faulkner announced changes to help address the lack of affordable housing for low income and middle-class families. We will speak with an economist about how effective some of the ideas might be, but first let's talk to at your bird to get a sense of what the proposals are. Thank you for joining us. By the way, these changes are only for the city of San Diego, housing and other cities defend does not depend on their local city councils. This could be setting a trend. The mayor announced a dozen initiatives, is there any extra money? In terms of new revenue not currently available, no. There are some measures that are meant to deploy the existing funds more quickly and efficiently, but raising more revenue for subsidized affordable housing would require a tax increase, a fee increase, and those will be difficult to pass. How about streamlining regulations for developers? That is one of the main themes. Overall they are aimed at building more housing and building it denser. There are incentives four -- for middle income housing and housing near public transport. How many of these ideas are new as opposed to initiatives already in the works? We have heard packages like this in the past. Correct. Most of the things on the list I was already aware of. A handful already have public hearings either at the planning commission or committee, but hadn't gotten the final approval. One was implementing a state law. That is kind of require by the city. Although, the city is doing it a little faster than what the state would require. A few were brand-new to me, if not new to people really plugged into this. I have gathered from speaking to some people who really know the inside of this from City Hall that the mayor has been contemplating this for a while. He has been seeking input, but some initiative to appear to be the first public announcement. Was to you think might make the most difference? The most intriguing to me was the middle income density bonus. This is building on the success of the affordable density bonus. When a developer agrees to include more subsidized affordable housing they get to bill more units on the existing plot of land. That is basically expanding on that to say if you agree to charge rent affordable to middle income people, people closer to the area, then you can build even more units. Another thing is changing parking requirements and projects located near public transit. Developers would have to include one unit for every -- I'm sorry, one parking space for every two units of housing. Otherwise, it might be one per one. The idea is when an apartment is near public transit residents are less likely to need a car, so why waste that car storage when it could be used for housing? But what about changes to the way planning commissions meet? They are the ones often blocking our higher density housing? That has something that has been brought up to councilmembers. I think that was not part of the mayor's announcement. It is something we could still see in the future, but it is going to be probably pretty controversial. Those community planning groups are pretty vested in the city. With supporting these proposals? Do developers like them? Absolutely. The main developer with at the press conference yesterday. Many of the issues have been on the developers wish list for years, but the port is not exclusive. There was the head of the housing, you matters coalition. That includes environmental groups. There is actually a broad consensus that the city needs more housing and the city should make it easier for developers to build. What needs to happen before any of these initiatives are implement it? Many of them would need city Council approval, at least review by the planning commission, the city will probably also go out to those stakeholder groups, community planning groups to get their input. The devil is in the details. We are going to be watching very closely at some of these proposals go forward. You get a sense that the mayor may be released the package because the county just released its ideas for how to increase affordable housing? Yes. I think this is something the mayor certainly promised with his state of the city address earlier this year. It is something that has been in the news a lot. We have all been reporting on housing affordability a lot. The timing is a little bit interesting because we just came out of this ex-pat between the mayor and the city Council over the budget and over his proposal to expand the commission center. This may be an opportunity for the mayor to extend the olive branch and say here is something that we can agree on, let us work together to solve this problem. Andrew, thank you so much. We are now joined by the chief economist at the point Loma Nazarene University of business and economics. Thank you for joining us. Thank you. You have looked over the mayor's ideas, which one strike you as especially promising? We are encouraged the efforts to streamline the whole process. The study that we did in 2013 showed in the city of San Diego about 47% of the cost of housing is due to regulation. A big part of that cost is just to the time required to get a project totally approved through the long process. The mayor's proposal does a lot to cut down that time dimension. Which specific puzzles to you think might be particularly helpful? I think the effort to give them an extended way to get through some of the environmental issues, to have a checklist to basically speed that through. The mayor also have a whole element of community plans, which can be a big part of the log jam. Another element besides the time gives builders and developers greater incentive to build housing for middle income households. That has been a group that has sort of become the forgotten part of our population. This is local initiatives, that the California equality act has rules that do make homes take longer to build and cause more money. Can local initiatives like the mayors do more to make housing more affordable? Is the state the main issue? Our study focused on the impact of local laws, restrictions, and fees. To the extent that local entities do not make restrictions even more aggressive than we do at the state level is constructed. We indicated that every 1% reduction in the cost of regulation could increase our housing supply by about 1%. Even at the margin there could be a very large impact. This is not the first time our elected politicians have tried to cut regulation in response to your conclusions that 47% of the cost of building a home in the city comes from regulation, is there evidence that development -- developers are passing the savings on to consumers? Competition with me that those savings will be passed on to households. It is hard to tell at this point because we are so far short of the demands that are now being exhibited. In the last three years 14,000 where people are leaving San Diego other than come again because of the cost of housing. These efforts are just a starting point, but they are important to tackle, a big element. Thank you so much for joining us. That is the chief economist at point lumen Nazarene University.

San Diego Unveils Affordable Housing Plan
San Diego officials Wednesday unveiled a dozen proposals designed to ease the city's lack of affordable housing.

San Diego officials Wednesday unveiled a dozen proposals designed to ease the high-cost city's lack of affordable housing.


The goals of the "Housing SD" plan are to spur the construction of low- income and middle-class housing through incentives, streamline development standards and speed up the review process, direct funding toward affordable housing and encourage growth in transit-friendly areas.

RELATED: Supervisors Approve Plan To Tackle Homelessness In San Diego

The latter point would support the city's plan to address climate change, according to the mayor's office.

San Diego Unveils Affordable Housing Plans

"The state's housing shortage and the unaffordable housing market it spawned has left the dream of homeownership out of reach for the majority of San Diegans," said Mayor Kevin Faulconer, who made the announcement at an affordable housing complex in Logan Heights.


"The only way to change that is to build more housing that people can actually afford," the mayor said. "Hardworking folks who love San Diego and want to live in San Diego should not be priced out of San Diego."

Last month, the California Association of Realtors reported that just 28 percent of San Diego households could afford to purchase a median-priced home in the area.

RELATED: New Survey: San Diego Voters Want Homeless Funding, Not Convention Center Expansion

"The housing affordability crisis is the top issue facing our city that is literally forcing the next generation of San Diegans to move outside the region," said Councilman Scott Sherman, who chairs a committee that deals with land-use issues.

The dozen proposals include:

–Creating incentives for developers to construct housing projects that provide units that can be sold or rented to entry-level or middle-income households.

–Updating regulations to allow builders to gain higher densities for their projects.

–Streamlining the review process for public and private development projects that are consistent with densities established by existing zoning, community plan or general plan policies for which an environmental impact report was certified.

–Reforming a develop impact fee system that discriminates against affordable units.

–Updating the city's 60-year-old parks master plan.

–Establishing a $20 million financing fund to encourage development near transit hubs.

Another provision, which would ease regulations on construction of auxiliary units or "granny flats," was recently given a nod by a City Council committee.

"Housing costs spiraling out of control impacts everyone, and everything we aspire to accomplish as a city," said Councilman Chris Ward. "These proposals are an important jumping off point to ensure we provide all the housing opportunities San Diegans need to succeed and thrive here."

RELATED: San Diego Set To Make It Easier To Build ‘Granny Flats’

Ward represents downtown, Hillcrest and North Park, areas where housing is expensive and the problem of homelessness has continued to grow.