Skip to main content

LATEST UPDATES: Tracking COVID-19 | Racial Justice

Details Of Midway Police Shooting Remain Under Wraps Despite Transparency Law

A San Diego police officer with a police dog waits outside a house with a pos...

Credit: Associated Press

Above: A San Diego police officer with a police dog waits outside a house with a possible suspect inside Friday, July 29, 2016.

Listen to this story by reporter Claire Trageser

In a ruling last week, a federal appeals court harshly criticized the San Diego Police Department's response to an officer’s 2015 shooting of Fridoon Rashawn Nehad, an unarmed man who was walking in an alley in the Midway District.

However, despite a new state law aimed at increasing transparency of police investigations, the public will not be able to access the records detailing this case any time soon.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals detailed mistakes made by San Diego Police Officer Neal Browder, who said he shot and killed Nehad because he thought he was armed with a knife. Nehad was actually carrying a pen.

"Even if Browder had reasonably perceived Nehad as holding a knife, a reasonable factfinder could conclude that Nehad did not pose a danger to anyone," the appeals court judge stated in his ruling.

RELATED: Family Of Man Killed By San Diego Police Has Suit Reinstated

Nehad’s case clearly falls within the scope of SB 1421. The law, which went into effect in January, allows public access to police records when an officer shoots someone, uses force that results in serious injury or death, or is found to have lied during an investigation or committed sexual assault.

The San Diego District Attorney's Office ruled Browder's shooting of Nehad was justified and Browder will not face criminal charges. However, Nehad's family is pursuing a civil lawsuit against the city over his death.

Because of that lawsuit, the city says the United States District Court has established a protective order over the records, said Matthew Halgren, a First Amendment attorney with Sheppard Mullin who is representing KPBS and other media outlets seeking to get police records.

“The city has stated that it will not disclose records relating to the shooting of Mr. Nehad while litigation regarding that shooting is ongoing because, it says, the court has issued a protective order prohibiting disclosure of those records.”

RELATED: How Police Departments Are Disclosing Records Under SB 1421

Halgren said anyone wanting access to the records would have to challenge the protective order in court.

Laila Aziz with the advocacy group Pillars of the Community said the reasoning that records should be kept private because of ongoing investigations or open lawsuits goes against the spirit of the law.

"That ongoing investigation excuse is just another reason to withhold information and to keep the people from having access to that information," she said.

Aziz said protective orders could also prevent public access to cases of other people killed by police.

The San Diego city attorney's office said they're reviewing the appellate court ruling.

San Diego News Now podcast branding

The San Diego Metropolitan Transit System plans to spend $34 million for a new “tap-and-go” fare collection system. Plus, despite a new state law aimed at increasing transparency of police investigations, the public will not be able to access records detailing the case of an officer killing a man armed with only a pen. Also on today’s podcast, a large ... Read more →

Aired: July 15, 2019 | Transcript

  • Need help keeping up with the news that matters most? Get the day's top news — ranging from local to international — straight to your inbox each weekday morning.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Photo of Claire Trageser

Claire Trageser
Investigative Reporter

opening quote marksclosing quote marksAs a member of the KPBS investigative team, my job is to hold the powerful in San Diego County accountable. I've done in-depth investigations on political campaigns, police officer misconduct and neighborhood quality of life issues.

Want more KPBS news?
Find us on Twitter and Facebook, or sign up for our newsletters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.