Former Deputy Charged With Murder In Detainee Shooting Pleads Not Guilty
Tuesday, July 14, 2020
Credit: Pool photo via CBS 8
A former San Diego County sheriff's deputy who fatally shot a fleeing detainee outside the downtown San Diego jail pleaded not guilty Tuesday to a second-degree murder charge.
Aaron Russell, 23, is charged in the May 1 death of 36-year-old Nicholas Bils, who was unarmed and running away from officers when he was shot just outside the San Diego Central Jail, according to the San Diego County District Attorney's Office.
Russell faces 15 years to life in state prison if convicted of second-degree murder, and up to an additional 10 years if convicted of firearm allegations. This is the first time an on-duty police officer in San Diego has been charged with murder in connection with a fatal officer-involved shooting, according to the DA's office.
The former deputy, who had been with the department for 18 months at the time of the shooting, surrendered to authorities on Monday, according to his attorney, Richard Pinckard.
Russell, who resigned from the sheriff's department shortly after the shooting, faces 15 years to life in state prison if convicted of second-degree murder, and up to an additional 10 years if convicted of a firearm allegation.
Bils had been arrested by rangers with the California Department of Parks and Recreation for allegedly threatening a ranger with a golf club at Old Town San Diego State Park. He was being transported to the downtown detention facility when he managed to escape from a California State Park Officer's car, according to San Diego police.
Deputy District Attorney Stephen Marquardt said Russell fired five times as Bils was running away, striking him in the back, arm and thigh. Iredale said the fatal shot went through Bils' back, lung and heart.
Among the officers present during the shooting, Russell was the only one who discharged his weapon, the prosecutor said. In fact, Marquardt said, "No other officer on scene so much as unholstered a firearm to stop Bils from running."
The Bils family's attorney, Eugene Iredale, said Bils was at the park that day hitting golf balls for his dog to chase. He said "it appears that when the park rangers approached him," Bils "brandished his golf club and ran away."
Iredale alleged that Russell opened fire "with what appears to be calmness and relaxation" as he "began to take target practice on a man who was fleeing."
Exactly what prompted the deputy to open fire remains unclear. The DA's Office said there is surveillance footage of the shooting, but it will not be released to the public at this time as it is now evidence in a pending criminal case.
Marquardt said Russell was unjustified in shooting Bils under a recently enacted state law that changed the standard governing when law enforcement officers are justified in using deadly force. Since the beginning of this year, peace officers may only use deadly force "when necessary in defense of human life."
Iredale said: "Five years ago or 10 years ago, such a prosecution, no matter how clear the facts were, and no matter how appropriate the prosecution, would have been hard to conceive."
In an interview with KPBS, community activist Tasha Williamson said she believes the charging of Russell is a response to recent protests against police brutality and political calculus on the part of District Attorney Summer Stephan.
"We understand why she’s doing it," Williamson said. "We also understand that we have yet to see officers charged when the victim of an officer-involved shooting is black."
Stephan, in a statement Monday, said her office "reached the decision to file criminal charges following a thorough review of all the objective facts and evidence in this case by specialized prosecutors and investigators in our Special Operations Division."
"When a life is taken, we must make decisions based in facts and law, and not ones that are influenced by the status of the accused as a peace officer nor the status of the victim," Stephan said. "These decisions must be made solely in the interest of justice and not based on favoritism nor public opinion. Every person must be accountable under the law."
The victim's mother, Kathleen Bils made a statement following Russell's arraignment, in which she said her son "should be alive and be here with us. But he's dead, and my heart cries out that this is not right."
She said the months since his death "have been agonizing for my sons, their families, and for me."
Bils' older brother, Benjamin Bils, said his sibling "was not a saint, (but) he was not a bad person."
He said his brother had run-ins with the police in the past, but "it did not mean he deserved to be shot in the back."
Russell was initially held on $1 million bail, but a judge cut the amount in half, agreeing with Russell's attorney that his client was not a flight risk or a danger to the community.
"He has based his entire life on the principles of honor and integrity," said Pinckard, who said law enforcement shootings "occur in tense, uncertain, rapidly evolving incidents, where decisions are literally being made in fractions of seconds."
Laila Aziz, program director for Pillars of the Community, a grassroots nonprofit in southeastern San Diego, warned the second-degree murder charge against Russell could be pleaded down.
"We’re going to have to watch it closely, from the motions to the preliminary hearing," Aziz said.
Russell is due back in court July 24 for a status conference.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.