skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

San Diego City Council Fine Tunes ‘Reform Before Revenue’ Initiative


Aired 8/2/10

The San Diego city council met briefly this morning to sort out final details of a ballot measure that would allow the city to raise the sales tax half a cent, but only AFTER certain conditions had been met.

The San Diego City Council met briefly this morning to sort out final details of a ballot measure that would allow the city to raise the sales tax half a cent, but only after certain conditions had been met.

The conditions include pension reforms and specific steps toward outsourcing some city services.

San Diego’s City Attorney Jan Goldsmith told the council he will not have the "reform before revenue” ballot measure ready for their approval until Wednesday. That’s just two days before a Friday deadline to get it on the November ballot.

Goldsmith said the city auditor would have to certify all the conditions had been met before the State Board of Equalization would agree to implement the tax.

“None of the conditions may be excused for any reason,” Goldsmith said, “including, but not limited to, inability to meet the conditions due to legal restrictions, or other unforeseen circumstances.”

Councilwoman Donna Frye said after the meeting that the list of reforms she drafted would not include attempts to reform legally vested pension benefits.

“What we did is try to craft this in a way that it could be accomplished without litigation,” she said. “So that you didn’t get into the debate about vested versus non-vested benefits.”

The reforms do include requiring elected officials and non-union employees to pay their own pension contributions, rather than the city.

Another condition establishes a program whereby city employees could choose to change from a defined benefit plan to a 401K pension plan. Goldsmith said the IRS may or may not approve this, but as long as the City Council agreed to it, the condition would be met.

San Diego City Councilman Carl DeMaio also wants the council to take a vote on Wednesday to decide whether or not to overturn the Mayor’s veto of a separate ballot measure: the initiative to build a new city hall.

DeMaio, who is against both a sales tax increase and a new city hall, said he is concerned that some council members might change their minds and decide to vote for a new city hall without taking the issue to the voters.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'oldschool'

oldschool | August 2, 2010 at 4:42 p.m. ― 6 years, 7 months ago

As soon as this FARCE TAX is on the books, the "reforms" will go out the window! It will be used for the Library, city hall, underfunded pensions, BS city hall after BS city hall BS!
STOP the grotesque ABUSE first. The UNIONS have destroyed this city... no more BS.
The Citizens pay enough tax! Look at this city Government as one of the worst in the nation... waste, abuse, fraud, mis-management, and in bed with the stinking unions.
Ram this tax, shi*ty Hall!

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'Mikesta'

Mikesta | August 3, 2010 at 12:11 p.m. ― 6 years, 6 months ago

In 2006 the voters approved an outsourcing measure. Our "Labor Controlled" Council refuses (that's right refuses!) to implement. Why would I believe they would do it in yet another ballot? Fool me once shame on you foll me twice shame on me.

( | suggest removal )