skip to main content

Listen

Read

Watch

Schedules

Programs

Events

Give

Account

Donation Heart Ribbon

SD County Employees Pocketed Pay Increase Despite Position Cuts

Audio

Aired 9/27/10

San Diego’s Watchdog Institute has published the county’s full payroll for 2007, 2008 and 2009. County payroll costs held steady over those years even as the number of people earning salaries above $100,000 grew.

— San Diego’s Watchdog Institute has published the county’s full payroll for 2007, 2008 and 2009. County payroll costs held steady over those years even as the number of people earning salaries above $100,000 grew.

Through 2007, San Diego County employed just over 19,000. Of those, nearly 800 earned annual salaries at or above $100,000.

By the end of 2009, when the economy was hitting rock bottom, the number of county staff had shrunk by about 3 percent. At the same time the number of people earning those higher salaries had grown by more than a quarter, to about 1,000 people.

What caused that increase? Part of it has to do with how county agencies managed to control payroll costs. The District Attorney’s office employed about 280 of these high wage earners in 2009 – more than any other department. The department’s chief administrator, Michelle Bush, said they are still cutting back in one of the only ways they can when it comes to compensation.

“One way that we have managed our salary and benefit is that we have over 120 positions vacant in our office, which is in excess of $10 million in positions.”

County agencies slowed or stopped hiring instead of laying people off. So now, the people who work there tend to have been there longer. And that means earning more money.

“The district attorneys are a professional classification. They are career classifications for most of the individuals, they do stay," Bush said. "They make the county a career. The longer they stay, they continue to advance along a natural progression for their professional classification, which includes increases.”

Pay for each class of worker is negotiated between the county’s human resources department and labor organizations. Those negotiations include regular pay increases that are laid out in formal agreements that span several years.

For example, 36 deputy district attorneys saw their salaries cross the $100,000 threshold in 2009 because of the pay increases spelled out in the agreement between the county and the attorneys’ association.

But the longevity of employees in county jobs tells Richard Rider that their salaries are just too high.

“There’s a simple way to tell if we’re over paying our government employees," said Richard Rider, president of San Diego Tax Fighters. "How many quit? Very few.”

Rider argued the pay increases should cause taxpayers some concern.

“I think it’s indicative of the fact that in the middle of a deep, prolonged recession they are continuing to raise pay," he said "This can’t be justified in a state that has the third highest employment rate in the country.”

Across the county employees earned an average salary of about $52,000. That’s $12,000 more than the median income of San Diego County residents the U.S. Census Bureau calculated a year earlier.

A report released earlier this year concluded the gap between state and local government pay and private sector pay was actually growing. The report pointed out that public employees tend to do jobs that require more education.

“The actual pattern of public sector earnings is that they’re much too low at the top of the distribution compared to the private sector," said John Heywood, an economic professor at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee and one of the report's authors. "So the medical examiner, the district attorney, usually take a wage cut relative to what they could earn in the private sector as a doctor or a lawyer.”

Michelle Bush of the District Attorney’s Office said that’s true of their staff.

“Our DDA1's start out around $55,000 to $60,000 a year," she said. "We’re talking about an attorney coming out of law school making $60,000 a year as opposed to what they may make in the private sector, which may be two to three times that amount.”

San Diego County’s tax revenues will drop by $48 million this fiscal year. With even less money coming in, how many people to employ and how much to pay them will probably remain tough questions for county officials to answer.

Comments

Avatar for user 'hrussell'

hrussell | September 27, 2010 at 10:33 a.m. ― 4 years, 1 month ago

What a unique idea? Less services for the public. Decrease size of work force by layoffs or having vacant positions remain unfilled. Have hefty pay raises to those that remain. Are these people really on our side?

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'Richard_Rider'

Richard_Rider | September 27, 2010 at 2:03 p.m. ― 4 years, 1 month ago

To see how out of touch government employees are with the private sector, consider this quote from the above article:

***Michelle Bush of the District Attorney’s Office said that’s true of their staff.

“Our DDA1's start out around $55,000 to $60,000 a year," she said. "We’re talking about an attorney coming out of law school making $60,000 a year as opposed to what they may make in the private sector, which may be two to three times that amount.”***

So it's common for private sector beginning attorneys to make $120K to $180K? Really???????

Not according to www.payscale.com. The median salary scale for new attorneys ranges from $45,384 to $69,351.

And the ones making the high range are expected to work 60-100 hours a week to get ahead. I seriously doubt county attorneys face such work requirements.

And then there's those WONDERFUL government pensions . . . .

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'msb'

msb | October 14, 2010 at 8:50 a.m. ― 4 years ago

Richard: Actually, the range of $45,384 to $69,351 is the median (not average) starting salary Payscale lists on a national basis. There are 3 crucial points you miss in your rant and rave:

1) When you change it to California or San Diego, it increases.

2) And even if you did not, can I point out that $55 - $60 K falls squarely in the middle of that national average.

3) The numbers you quoted from Payscale, that is combined public, private, nonprofit sectors, including self-employed attorneys. Do you think the number comes in lower because of the public sector and nonprofit sector wages?

Michelle Bush was saying they could make more in the private sector - you did not compare the salary ranges to that of the private sector only, but you tried to analyze it that way and make your point sound as if you did. And I know you did not because I just went into payscale and saw how you did get the numbers.

So your big point here, is that on a NATIONWIDE basis, a starting attorney overall - private + public + nonprofit sectors combined, the starting salary could be about 5K less than in San Diego?

And again, that is not even really true since within the range of $45,384 to $69,351 the middle point is $57,367 - so that would put San Diego just below the mid point of the median range, and that is based on the national average, and as San Diego is a more expensive City than the national average, combined with the fact that your numbers are not based on ONLY the private sector, then Michelle Bush is correct in saying that starting attorneys could make more in the private sector in San Diego specifically.

Sounds like a lot of ranting and raving just for the sake of ranting and raving.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'msb'

msb | October 18, 2010 at 4:33 p.m. ― 4 years ago

Jobs in San Diego's Private Sector make up the majority of employment with 1,108,625 jobs in the San Diego, CA surrounding area (San Diego County).

This accounts for 83.62% of the San Diego jobs market.

Government jobs only account for just 16.38% of the total workforce in San Diego, and that is state, local, federal combined.

Data Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, Q3 2007 - http://jobs.aol.com/jobs-by-city/san-diego-ca-jobs/

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'msb'

msb | October 18, 2010 at 4:34 p.m. ― 4 years ago

National Association of Law Placement supports Michelle Bush’s statement that attorneys right out of law school may make 2 – 3 times as much in the private sector:

“The $160,000 first-year salary still offered at many big firms in big cities — or even $145,000 or $130,000 — is beyond what even the most experienced attorneys can reasonably expect at a public sector or public interest organization.”

http://www.nalp.org/assoc_pi_sal2010

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'msb'

msb | October 18, 2010 at 4:37 p.m. ― 4 years ago

Payscale demonstrates that government as an employer type is in the BOTTOM third (5 from the lowest employer types out of 15) in terms of salary, along with nonprofits and contract work.

http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Attorney_%2f_Lawyer/Salary/by_Employer_Type

( | suggest removal )