skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

Counting Bike Trips Could Get More People To Pedal

Aired 12/19/12 on KPBS News.

A program to monitor bike use in San Diego County seeks a way to improve the cycling environment.

— There was a light rain falling in Balboa Park where a small group of well-dressed people came to make an announcement. They found a dry place under a magnolia tree. One of them was county health officer Dean Sidelinger, who was there to talk about Bikes Count.

"With Bikes Count, San Diego now has the largest regional, interconnected automatic bicycle and pedestrian counting system in the country," he said.

SDSU Professor Sherry Ryan poses over an electronic loop, embedded in the street, that keeps track of the number of bikes which travel on that route.

People who build and maintain freeways have lots of information about how many motorists use them. But we don't know much about bike riders on city streets. Bikes Count aims to change that.

The bike-monitoring program began with a $16 million grant to the San Diego County Health Department. It paid for the installation of electronic sensors in 28 locations in San Diego County. There are monitors in 13 cities. Sixteen locations are in the City of San Diego.

Muggs Stoll, the planning director for SANDAG, said when you're building roads or bike paths, you need a little info.

"If you're running a business or creating a program,” said Stoll, “you want to know about your existing customers. Where are they? What are they doing? What are their patterns? That's what this data is all about."

One of the bike sensors is on 5th Avenue. There, a handful of bike enthusiasts rode across it for the benefit of the TV cameras. Sherry Ryan is a public affairs professor at San Diego State University, and is with SDSU's Active Transportation Research Center. She manages Bikes Count and she crunches the numbers.

"So we have a small computer basically installed in the sidewalk,” she said, describing the technology. “It's attached to an inductive loop that runs out into the asphalt. And when a cyclist goes over the loop, it triggers a count."

The bike sensors have been in place now for about three months, and they tell us a lot about bike traffic volume in San Diego. The number of daily bike trips, on a given road, can range from 25 to 2,500.

The counts also tell you something about why people are riding. For instance, one sensor in La Jolla has shown lots of traffic on the weekends. That indicates a lot of recreational cyclists. But Ryan says it's a different story at monitored locations in Vista and El Cajon.

Some cyclists approach a bike trip scanner, embedded in the street on 5th Avenue in San Diego.

"When look at those numbers we see peaking on a Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. Just based on my experience going out to those locations, mostly low-income Hispanic cyclists getting to work," she said.

Safety clearly makes a difference when it comes to motivating cyclists. The new bike data show that bike paths, which keep bikes separate from car traffic, are the most popular. Unmarked bike routes come in second, while bike lanes, which are marked with stripes of paint, come in last, probably because so many of them are on roads heavily used by cars.

Ryan's San Diego cycling profile also relies on human counters who observe bike traffic. She said their observations are pretty interesting.

"Probably about 80 to 90 percent of cyclists are men. We're provided a system that doesn't serve women. We don't feel safe. We don't feel comfortable,” said Ryan.

Another thing human counters notice is how many people ride on sidewalks, as opposed to the street. Again, it’s a sign of the strong desire of bicyclists not to share their path with cars.

“This data has to come together to support building infrastructure," said Ryan.

There is some money for that. About two percent of San Diego's Transnet tax is dedicated to walking and biking infrastructure. About $2.5 billion of SANDAG's 40-year transportation plan goes to what they call active transportation. Keep in mind that's a small portion of a plan that totals $200 billion.

Cycling enthusiast Hans Wangbichler attended the announcement of the Bikes Count project. He said he'd like to see a protected bike lane, called a cycle track, from downtown to Hillcrest… one very common trip in the central city. But where do you put it? He said the monitoring program could help answer that question.

"Maybe they put it on one of the roads and they find out, well… we're hardly getting any readings on this road. Maybe we shouldn't be putting our cycle track there," said Wangbichler.

Biking is good for the environment and good for health. But it's not always safe, and the U.S. Census has found that less than 1 percent of San Diego county commuters use it as their mode of transportation. Could investment in the right kind of roads and bike paths boost that number a bit? That's the hope.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'wpstoll'

wpstoll | December 20, 2012 at 10:35 a.m. ― 4 years, 3 months ago

Professor Ryan states correctly that women don't feel safe or comfortable riding in San Diego. I'm a 56 year old man and I don't feel safe or comfortable on local class I bikeways like the Ocean Beach bike path along the San Diego River. Same goes for the Rose Creek bike path in Pacific Beach. Transients have twice attempted strong arm robbery of my bicycle as I rode through in the early morning darkness on my way to work. Riding through their trash and feces strewn camps can be hazardous when dozens of people are hauled out like harbor seals in sleeping bags across the path with no barrier and sharp riprap along the riverbed. Until the political will exists to keep these bike paths clear of this kind of danger, it will continue to discourage cycling commuters of both sexes from using these expensive facilities that the City wants to give away as plein air insane asylums and homeless shelters.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'radiofree'

radiofree | December 24, 2012 at 6:02 p.m. ― 4 years, 2 months ago

I ride my bike on the sidewalk when I can because I want to avoid the added risk of riding with cars. Most drivers do OK with cyclists but it only takes 1 driver trying to text while driving to ruin a nice ride. The sidewalk where I ride is usually empty anyway.

( | suggest removal )

Avatar for user 'CanyonBluffsBill'

CanyonBluffsBill | September 21, 2013 at 11:21 a.m. ― 3 years, 6 months ago

I hope the research directs planners to a wise placement and purchase of cycling infrastructure. Fudge wrote: "About two percent of San Diego's Transnet tax is dedicated to walking and biking infrastructure. About $2.5 billion of SANDAG's 40-year transportation plan goes to what they call active transportation. Keep in mind that's a small portion of a plan that totals $200 billion." Later in the article he reports "...the U.S. Census has found that less than 1 percent of San Diego county commuters use [cycling] as their mode of transportation." Yes, $2.5 billion may seem like a small amount, but in the context of how many local commuters actually ride their bikes, it seems proportional to me.
I commute by bicycle most days, so I'm all for making streets as safe as possible. I'm not convinced though, that spending exorbitant amounts of money on infrastructure will automatically translate into more cyclists. Dedicated cycle tracks along heavily traveled corridors makes economic sense if a lot of cyclists are already traveling along those corridors.

( | suggest removal )