California Coastal Commission Ousts Its Chief
Charles Lester fired in a 7-5 vote following a 12-hour hearing filled with his supporters
Wednesday, February 10, 2016
UPDATE: 9:45 p.m., Feb. 10, 2016
The powerful agency that manages development on California's fabled coastline has voted to oust its top executive.
The 7-5 vote by the California Coastal Commission came after an impassioned hearing of nearly 12 hours Wednesday in Morro Bay that ended in the ouster of Executive Director Charles Lester.
Dozens of witnesses, from environmentalists to surfers, spoke in support of Lester's leadership and warned that his dismissal could open the way for unchecked development.
The commission then went into closed session shortly before 8 p.m. When they emerged, Lester was quickly dismissed.
Lester got an ovation from some in the crowd and said he was disappointed but it was a privilege to serve.
The shake-up raised questions about the direction of an agency often caught in the clash between property rights and conservation.
One of the commissioners voting to fire Lester was Escondido City Councilwoman Olga Diaz, who was there as an alternate for San Diego County Supervisor Greg Cox, who could not attend the meeting.
Diaz described herself as an environmentalist who came to the meeting wondering, "What am I missing?" But she said there was an issue the commissioners were legally unable to disclose that led to the decision to terminate Lester.
The powerful agency that manages development on California's coastline considered whether to fire its chief executive Wednesday as it faced a packed room of sign-holding supporters who want him kept on the job.
Hundreds of people filled a meeting room to capacity, with scores more outside, in what amounted to a striking show of support for Charles Lester, executive director of the California Coastal Commission. Many waved signs saying "More Lester" and "Save Our Coast," and supporters chanted outside: "We want Lester."
The potential shake-up raises questions about the direction of an agency often caught in the clash between property rights and conservation. The panel has broad sway over construction and environmental issues in coastal areas that include some of the most coveted real estate in the U.S.
The biggest question has been what Lester has done wrong: The commission, which met briefly behind closed doors before hearing testimony, has not provided a reason for his proposed dismissal.
Environmental activists suspect some commission members want to push him out to make way for management that would be more favorable to development, while a business group has questioned the tactics of the agency's staff.
Lester told the commission on Wednesday he and his staff are committed to preserving access to California’s shoreline for everyone, not just those fortunate enough to live on the coast.
"We do this in the face of immense pressures to develop some of the most valuable real estate in the world," he said. "We are striving to protect a precious geography and build resilient communities, not just for ourselves but for our children and their children and their children."
The commission heard from more than a dozen witnesses Wednesday, including members of its staff, all supporting Lester's work. They praised him for his balanced hand in regulation and thorough and independent evaluation of proposed projects along the coastline.
Serge Dedina, the mayor of Imperial Beach, spoke in support of Lester and his staff. He said the Coastal Commission is newly focused on sea level rise, allowing his city to shift its focus from "dredge-and-fill projects" that waste taxpayer funds.
"That’s something we are whole-heartedly moving forward with," Dedina said. "It actually resulted in the largest and most well-attended public workshop in our city’s history, with our residents completely embracing that strategy."
Susan Jordan of the California Coastal Protection Network warned that Lester's removal could threaten beach access for the public and open a new era of unchecked development.
"There will always be another billionaire who will block access to the beach," she warned, alluding to notorious fights over beaches in Malibu and other celebrity enclaves.
William L. Perocchi, chief executive of the Pebble Beach Co., which owns the famed seaside golf course, submitted a letter to the panel calling Lester "fair, pragmatic, creative, open and reasonable."
Commission Chairman Steve Kinsey notified Lester in a letter last month that the panel will consider whether to fire him. Lester has held the post since 2011.
The 12-member commission has received about 29,000 letters and emails, virtually all of them supporting Lester's leadership.
But a letter from the Los Angeles County Business Federation, an alliance of 155 business groups, faulted the commission's staff for a lack of accountability and regulatory overreach.
"California Coastal Commission staff attempt to assert control over facilities, projects and land use" outside of their control, according to the letter received by the panel Wednesday.
Lester has aggressively defended his tenure and depicted himself as an able steward of the coast. He has said he and the commission have made strides addressing the effects of sea-level rise tied to climate change, protecting open space and winning additional funding.
He defended his record for nearly 40 minutes Wednesday, stressing the need for an independent, impartial staff to review projects, with the commission then voting on those recommendations.
"If the two intertwine, then the recommendation or the commission decision ... will be untrustworthy," he warned.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.