skip to main content









Donation Heart Ribbon

District 1 Race Could Shift Balance Of Power On SD City Council

Above: Denniz Ridz, Sherri Lightner, Bryan Pease and Ray Ellis, all candidates for City Council District 1.

Aired 5/24/12 on KPBS Midday Edition.


Ray Ellis, businessman.

Sherri Lightner, City Councilwoman, District 1.

Bryan Pease, public interest attorney.

Dennis Ridz, SANDAG representative and member of the San Diego County Redistricting Committee.


San Diego City Council District 1 boundaries.  The newly redrawn council dist...
Enlarge this image

Above: San Diego City Council District 1 boundaries. The newly redrawn council district will take effect in December 2012.

The four candidates for San Diego City Council District 1 are making that election one of the most competitive this year.

They represent a wide variety pf backgrounds: Ray Ellis, a Republican businessman; Sherri Lightner, a Democrat and current District 1 representative; Bryan Pease, a Democratic public interest attorney; and Dennis Ridz, a Republican who has served as a SANDAG representative and member of the San Diego County Redistricting Committee.

Despite new district boundaries created last year, 94 percent of District 1 remains the same. The district includes San Diego coastal communities from Pacific Beach, La Jolla and Del Mar Heights inland to Carmel Valley, Sorrento Valley and University City.

The four candidates spoke to KPBS about their stances on a wide variety of issues.

Pease and Ridz said they oppose the One Paseo development planned for a lot on El Camino Real and Del Mar Heights. Ellis said he supports a "scaled down" version of the project, and Lightner said she could not state her opinion, because it would mean she would have to recuse herself from future City Council votes on it.

Only Pease is opposed to Proposition B, the plan to change future city pensions to 401(k)s. Ellis and Lightner support the measure, and Ridz said he supports it, but only as an entry point to starting discussions with unions.

Ridz and Pease were the only candidates willing to make an outright endorsement for San Diego mayor. Pease supports Congressman Bob Filner, and Ridz supports state Assemblyman Nathan Fletcher, or "anyone but (City Councilman) Carl DeMaio," he added. Ellis said he supports "anybody but Bob Filner" and Lightner said she was not endorsing anyone.

Each City Council candidate had similar opinions on whether to build a new stadium for the San Diego Chargers.

"I support moving forward with examining a multi-use facility that would include the Chargers," Ellis said. "I think we need to make every attempt to keep them here, but it can't be on the backs of taxpayers."

"I think having the Chargers here is great, just not at taxpayer expense, the taxpayers shouldn't be paying for a new stadium," Pease said.

"I love the Chargers but no money and no land, and it should go to a vote of the people," Lightner said.

"I'll start by saying I've been a season ticket holder for 22 years and I do support my Chargers, but the city at this point can't really afford to get involved in this issue," Ridz said. "The NFL and the owners certainly have enough to do this."

The top two vote-getters in the June 5 primary will move on to the general election in November.

Evening Edition

Sherri Lightner and Ray Ellis, both candidates for District 1, talk to KPBS.

Evening Edition

Bryan Pease and Dennis Ridz, both candidates for District 1, talk to KPBS.

To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.


Avatar for user 'Roberto Rolando Salinas'

Roberto Rolando Salinas | May 25, 2012 at 11:35 a.m. ― 4 years, 10 months ago

I heard the roundtable on midday with the candidates. Thank you for the program it was very interesting and insightful. I was very impressed with Mr. Byran Pease. I don't live in that district but if I did he would be my choice. He seemed to be the candidate that best understood the delicate nature of of going forward with pension reform. He seemed to be staunchly defending city employees against the flagrant abuses Prop B would impose with a 401K retirement plan. He also has vast experience in another very delicate and complex subject matter, the environment. I was very impressed, and though I can't support him in the voting booth I hope he is successful in his political career. We need compassionate, caring elected officials, who believe in public service, not corporate service, as is now the case in city and county governments.

( | suggest removal )