The Truth About Nathan Fletcher: Mayoral Candidate Reveals Abusive Childhood (Video)
Monday, November 4, 2013
SAN DIEGO In May of 1979, Randy Fletcher was 28 and unemployed when he traveled nearly 1,900 miles to Smackover, Ark. to retrieve his 2 ½-year-old son Nathan and return him to Carson City, Nev. Armed with a court order and a revolver, Fletcher was prepared for a confrontation with his ex-wife, Sherrie.
Aired 11/4/13 on KPBS News.
In an exclusive interview with our media partner inewsource, mayoral candidate Nathan Fletcher talked about a “living hell” with his biological father. Fletcher says he made the revelations hoping to set the record straight after questions about his past began surfacing in the campaign.
Special Feature Special Election
“...She has kept weapons in her presence in the past,” he testified during a custody hearing.
“I felt that if she had one of the weapons, obviously, I would not be able to get Nathan, but that, you know, I would probably have to leave and try again,” he said.
Nathan Fletcher doesn’t remember that day, but what he does remember is “a living hell” his father’s home became after his mother lost custody. His biological father had “wild swings from very violent to very apologetic ... It doesn’t make a lot of sense then, it doesn’t make any more sense today.”
Fletcher, a former California assemblyman and second time candidate for San Diego mayor, sat down Sunday afternoon with his mother, Sherrie Graham, in the KPBS studios for an exclusive interview with inewsource about his childhood. Although he said he has rarely revisited details of his young life, his past is becoming part of the campaign.
“I’ve done my best to try to protect my family and protect what little privacy you can when you run for office,” he said. “Like so many families out there, my life experience doesn’t fit neatly in a 30-second sound bite.”
Fletcher and the other mayoral candidates are facing intense scrutiny of their personal histories from the media in a campaign that follows the disgraceful exit of Mayor Bob Filner in August. Filner resigned after more than a dozen women alleged he either sexually harassed them or behaved inappropriately.
Polls suggest Fletcher is likely to make it to a runoff. If none of the candidates receive more than 50 percent of the vote Nov. 19, they will face off early next year.
In stump speeches Fletcher, who’s morphed from Republican to independent to Democrat in little over a year, has spoken of his working class parents, his factory worker father who became a cop, his mother an advocate for battered women. Some of his comments have appeared inconsistent, and he’s taken heat for refusing to release certain information to the media, such as his college transcripts.
The Sunday interview filled in gaps in records inewsource obtained from the courts in Carson City. Together, they paint a picture of a traumatic childhood, and suggest an explanation for the ambiguous narrative Fletcher has publicly presented.
(Fletcher’s parents’ divorce and custody battle were first reported in the San Diego Reader in 2012).
inewsource used public documents and online research tools in an attempt to locate Randy Fletcher without success.
In the beginning….
Sherrie Morgan was 18 when she married Randy Fletcher. He was 25, but according to Sherrie, Randy lied about his age and told her he was just 21.
It was the first in a series of Randy’s lies, Sherrie told the court in her battle for Nathan. He lied about graduating from college, about having a sister in the Peace Corps, about being the nephew of an NBA referee.
And he failed to tell the Carson City Sheriff’s Department he had a glass eye, something that could have disqualified him from becoming a deputy sheriff, a job from which he was eventually fired.
“He lies, and I don’t think he can help it, and there is several instances during our marriage, and since our marriage, during our separation, and since our divorce, that he has showed me that he is just not always what he appears to be….,” Sherrie told the court.
Sherrie and Randy had known each other less than a year when they married in 1975. Nathan was born on New Year’s Eve one year later, Dec. 31, 1976.
Two years later the Fletchers were divorced. Sherrie had custody and Randy was granted visitation on weekends. Without the court’s permission and without telling Nathan’s father, Sherrie took off with her son to Arkansas.
“This was a very abusive relationship and I had to get Nathan out and so when we separated I was stalked everywhere I went. One time my car had no brakes in it. I couldn’t live there anymore and I took Nathan and I moved to Arkansas, where I had family,” Graham said Sunday.
Sherrie arrived in Arkansas Jan. 9, 1979. She met Danny Farley the next day and married him 18 days later.
Farley worked as a laborer at the International Paper Company in a neighboring town, earning $14,000 a year.
The newly-configured family began life in a rented, neatly kept two-bedroom, green-sided house in Smackover, a town of just four square miles, population 2,000, with “maybe nine or 10” Baptist churches, according to the town’s mayor.
Nathan began calling Farley “Dad.”
Throughout the campaign, Fletcher has either called his dad a cop, a factory worker, or both. His biological father was a cop for a while. Farley worked at a paper factory until it closed down. He currently works as a court security officer for a private company, contracted out by the U.S. Marshals Service.
Who is Fletcher referring to?
“When I say my dad, I’m talking about my stepdad, that’s the only dad that I know. It’s the dad who raised me, he took care of me, I called him dad,” Fletcher said. “I understand in a campaign people will look for any little thing that they can try to distort or take out of context or twist, but it’s always been clear for me.”
In Smackover, Sherrie, Danny and Nathan settled into their new life. They attended services at the Joyce City Baptist Church every Sunday, Sherry taught Sunday School, Danny coached softball.
“Nathan is much like many toddlers his age: As long as he is not too hungry or too sleepy he behaves pretty well,” his mother was quoted as saying at the time.
All the while, Randy Fletcher was in court, trying to get legal custody. By April, he was successful. May 1, he arrived in Smackover to take his son.
The following is Sherrie’s testimony about what happened that day:
“I was in the backyard hanging out clothes. Nathan was just a few feet away from me. Nathan saw his father.
“I believe he was hiding behind a tree, and he saw his father, and I screamed, and I lunged for Nathan, at which time I fell down.
“Randy picked Nathan up and took off running, at which time I followed them screaming, and there was a car waiting in the middle of the road running, and Randy and Nathan got in the car.”
Sherrie’s mother-in-law later found a gun on the ground.
Randy testified how it got there:
“As I picked Nathan up, I had him on my right shoulder, which, as I will admit, I do have an artificial right eye, not good for me to control a boy, or hold a boy on my right shoulder.
“I was in the process of running from her (Sherrie). I switched him from my right shoulder to my left shoulder, and with the combination of that with the running, Nathan kicked it (the gun) from my belt, and it dropped to the ground as I was running away from her.”
“It took approximately five minutes before he started talking to me, referring to things outside of the car,” Randy Fletcher told the court.
“I would describe the relationship as better than most father/son relationships, and its a very good relationship, considering his age and the experience he has had in the past. I’m proud of the relationship we have.”
Fletcher vs Fletcher
Back in Carson City, a new battle over the custody of Nathan Fletcher played out in a District Courtroom in June 1979. His father was made out to be a liar and emotionally unstable; his mother’s relationships scrutinized.
But there is insight too: a father who loved baseball, whose dream it was to finish college, who made friends easily; a mother who kept an immaculate home, a room full of toys for her son, who played the piano.
The judge in the case ordered home visits for both parents and ultimately described the decision he had to make when choosing who should have custody as difficult.
“...one which I do not relish, and I would like the benefit of just privately considering these things before I enter an order,” Judge Michael Fondi said in July 1979. “So I will take the matter under advisement at this time and I will enter an order in this matter tomorrow.”
The court transcript of the custody battle ends there, with just a single page in the court file indicating Randy Fletcher maintained legal custody, Sherrie appealed, but the appeal was denied.
When inewsource asked Fletcher to talk about life with his father, he began carefully, neutrally. But each consecutive sentence gained emotion.
“The first couple of years were, I guess, OK,” he said. “And then it just became a progressively worse environment, I guess.”
In what way?
“He wasn’t a good person. It was an environment that over time became a living hell. the last year in particular I was there was really bad.”
Did your father hit you?
“Yeah, he was abusive physically and mentally and verbally.”
He remembers missing a lot of school, a “place of refuge.”
“I remember being asked one time my least favorite class and I said math and someone asked why, and I didn’t have the heart to explain cause it was the last class of the day and I just didn’t want to go home.”
Graham said she recalls seeing bruises on Fletcher when he was 7 or 8 during one of his visits. “I was horrified,” she said. “That was the first time I really, really knew things had changed. He was more withdrawn and couldn’t focus and Nathan has always had amazing focus.”
As a child you think things are your fault, Fletcher said.
Today, he says with conviction, “Without question the lowest form of life on this planet is someone that would beat their wife or child. I don’t understand it now and I don’t think I ever will.”
Life for Nathan Fletcher changed again when he was 8. His father returned him to his mother because Nathan had been a “disruptive influence in his household,” according to court records.
Nathan Fletcher told inewsource he doesn’t know why his father sent him back to his mother. He said he was just told one day to pack his things. He remembers the plane ride to Arkansas and the reunion with his mother.
“We grew up together,” he said of his mother. “My mom was a teenager when she had me. We went through a lot together. I can’t say enough about having a strong steady loving figure in your life. That’s made all the difference for me. I couldn’t be prouder of my mom.”
Fletcher calls his stepfather “a solid guy.” Farley and Sherrie divorced after 19 years of marriage, and Fletcher said he lost touch with him.
He said he’s spent more time thinking about his past in the last week than he has in the last 30 years. And last week, he called Farley. Fletcher said he told his stepfather he appreciated all he had done for him, and Farley told him he’d been following the campaign online.
“He told me he was proud of me and that meant a lot,” Fletcher said.
The College Years
Once he moved to Smackover with his mom and stepdad his life was good and continually got better, Fletcher said.
He graduated from Smackover High in 1995 and came west to California. He attended California Baptist University, a private school founded by the California Southern Baptist Convention.
Despite growing up in a Baptist family, Fletcher says he was not a Baptist when he entered college nor when he left. He was a scholarship student who worked a series of jobs to pay his way, played baseball and was on the debating team, known as “Forensics.”
“We were both working our way through college and one of the ways we did that was on the speech and debate team,’ Fletcher’s college friend David Warren says.
“We were looking for scholarships anywhere they would give them to us,” Warren says.
Warren and Fletcher stayed friends over the years, even became neighbors.
Warren, a registered Republican, is an enthusiastic supporter of Fletcher for mayor. He recalls his college friend as competitive and hard working.
“I think he’s worked hard since he was younger than college. I think that’s how he grew up. I think that’s how his folks taught him to go through life, is to work hard for things,” Warren says.
Warren says Fletcher didn’t talk a lot about his family or childhood, “just funny stories.”
“Neither one of us are real big navel-gazers, we’re not psych majors, and so we didn’t go deep into family formation type things,” but adds, Fletcher’s mom is a “real sweetheart.”
Fletcher should have graduated in 2000, but he didn’t get his degree in political science until 2005. He says he was four credits short and fulfilled the requirement online in 2005, after serving his first tour of duty in the Marine Corps.
Earlier in the campaign, Fletcher claimed to be the first in his family to go to college.
In fact, his biological father attended the University of Oregon for four years but never graduated. He had 175 quarter hours, he needed 186.
In the interview Sunday, Fletcher said he didn’t know about his father’s education. “I was so little,” he said.
Councilmember Kevin Faulconer, also running for mayor, has called on Fletcher to release his college transcripts. Both he and Councilmember David Alvarez, another mayoral candidate, have already done so.
In an interview last week with inewsource, Fletcher said his campaign has released thousands of pages of records, including his military records, donor information and tax returns. The request for his transcripts is a “political sideshow,” he said. “The next thing’s going to be dental records.”
Much of Fletcher’s life after college has been written about: a Marine who served two tours of duty with an exemplary military record; a two-term California assemblyman; a prominent Republican who made headlines when he became an Independent and raised eyebrows when he became a Democrat; married to Mindy Fletcher, once an influential Republican campaign strategist who was senior advisor to the Bush/Cheney campaign in 2004, and deputy chief of staff to former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.
Mindy Fletcher also left the Republican Party last year, but she remains an Independent with no immediate plans to become a Democrat. She is a principal in her own government and public relations firm, 7 Second Strategies.
They have two adopted sons, Caleb, 2 and Zach, 5.
It would be difficult for anyone to hear their family’s most hurtful and personal details revealed in public, especially some thirty years later while running for political office.
With personal political scandal in the zeitgeist — family histories are excavated — and social media makes them lore.
Nathan Fletcher is now 36 years old. He’s never read the court custody records. He hasn’t talked to his biological father since he was a kid. And he’s talked about his very young years so rarely that even his mother said she didn’t know the details until Saturday after she flew in from Arkansas.
Asked whose idea it was that she do the inewsource interview with Fletcher, Graham said, “He didn’t deserve any of this, he did nothing. I just can’t imagine him talking about this without me here.”
Fletcher has run for public office before, but he’s never experienced such intensity around his personal life. And he hopes speaking out will help.
“My stepdad has been getting all of these calls, and my mom’s been getting all of these calls, and they’re not running. They’re not candidates. I chose this, I chose to run. I’m fair game,” he said. “There’s a hope that in talking about it once folks can hear the story and then move on. Let’s leave my family alone.”
inewsource investigative researcher Emily Burns contributed to this report.
To view PDF documents, Download Acrobat Reader.