skip to main content

Listen

Read

Watch

Schedules

Programs

Events

Give

Account

Donation Heart Ribbon

Judge Orders Authorities To Provide Lawyers For Mentally Ill In Immigration Detention

Audio

Aired 4/25/13

A federal judge ruled in a class action lawsuit that immigration detainees with mental illnesses have a right to legal counsel and a speedy bond hearing.

For the first time, a group of detainees accused of immigration violations will be given the right to legal counsel.

A federal judge in Los Angeles ruled that authorities must provide detainees facing deportation with an attorney if they’re found incapable of representing themselves due to mental illness.

Because immigration court is not part of the criminal justice system, defendants are normally required to hire their own lawyer or represent themselves.

Judge Dolly M. Gee also ruled that mentally disabled detainees should be given a bond hearing to avoid unnecessary long-term detention.

Sean Riordan, staff attorney for the ACLU of San Diego and Imperial Counties, said the ruling would provide “a critical protection” to mentally disabled individuals facing deportation proceedings.

“We’re talking about a group of people who often have such severe impairments that there’s no possible way that they could represent their interests adequately in court,” said Riordan, who worked on the class action lawsuit that spawned the ruling.

The ACLU and other groups sued the government three years ago on behalf of six mentally disabled detainees in Arizona, California and Washington. One of the plaintiffs, Jose Antonio Franco, was held in immigration detention centers in California for four and a half years after authorities determined he was mentally incapable of representing himself in immigration court.

“It’s clear in those cases that the indefinite detention they were suffering under wasn’t even necessary,” Riordan said. “It was just sort of a matter of administrative ease or the bureaucracy of the immigration detention system.”

Riordan said the judge’s decision ordering bond hearings for mentally ill detainees after six months in custody would prevent such situations.

The judge’s ruling came just a day after Justice Department and immigration authorities announced they would begin evaluating detainees with mental illnesses to determine their ability to represent themselves in immigration proceedings.

Authorities also announced that they would appoint counsel to those determined mentally incompetent.

Nevertheless, Riordan said the judge’s ruling was important to solidify the policy change.

“Without the court’s order the government would have been free to change its mind,” Riordan said.

In a statement, U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement said it "believes its new procedures will provide enhanced protections to unrepresented immigration detainees with serious mental disorders or conditions that may render them mentally incompetent to represent themselves in immigration proceedings."

The agency anticipates fully implementing the procedures by the end of the year.

A section of the Senate immigration reform bill currently under debate calls for appointing counsel "if necessary" to unaccompanied immigrant minors and people with severe mental disabilities.

Please stay on topic and be as concise as possible. Leaving a comment means you agree to our Community Discussion Rules. We like civilized discourse. We don't like spam, lying, profanity, harassment or personal attacks.

comments powered by Disqus