The San Diego City Council on Tuesday punted a decision on adopting a new structure of water rates that would lower bills for apartment buildings but increase them for most single-family homes.
The proposal is intended to bring the city into compliance with Proposition 218, a voter initiative from 1996 that regulates fees charged by local governments, including fees for water service.
In 2015, a group of water customers sued San Diego, arguing the city's tiered rate structure for single-family homes violated Prop 218, which requires water agencies to charge customers no more than their proportional cost of the service.
The city argued the higher rates charged to the heaviest water users were a lawful way to incentivize conservation. But the courts sided with the plaintiffs, finding the city had not presented enough evidence to justify its tiered water rates.
"Public Utilities Department does not agree with the court," said San Diego Chief Infrastructure Officer Kris McFadden. "However, we legally required to have a rate structure that the court deems valid under Proposition 218. The city must implement a unitary rate structure for our rates to be in compliance with the court ruling."
Under the proposed unitary rate structure, all customers would pay the same amount per gallon regardless of water consumption or building type. The proposal would not bring in more revenue overall. Rather some customers would pay more while others would pay less.
Three council members — Stephen Whitburn, Marni von Wilpert and Sean Elo-Rivera — were absent from Tuesday's meeting. A procedural vote to advance the conversation passed 5-1, with Councilmember Henry Foster III voting "no."
Faced with the possibility of the proposal failing, Council President Joe LaCava proposed delaying the vote until Oct. 27. His motion passed 5-1, with Councilmember Foster again voting "no."
"I think it's important that all three of (the absent council members), or as much as we can get together, need to weigh in and make sure that we have a healthy and robust discussion on water rates," LaCava said.
San Diego charges a flat monthly water service fee as well as a "volumetric" charge that's based on water usage.
San Diego currently has seven different volumetric rates for different kinds of customers. Single-family homes are divided into three tiers — for low, average and high users — while separate rates are charged to apartment buildings, businesses, irrigation customers and temporary construction sites.
Under the proposed new rate structure, all water customers would be charged the same volumetric rate — $11.09 per hundred cubic feet, equivalent to about 748 gallons. The fixed monthly charge would continue to vary based on the size of the customer's water meter.
The city estimates the new unitary rate would result in apartment buildings saving between 2.2% and 2.6% on the average water bill. Single-family homes in the heaviest usage tier would see savings of around 5.9%, while irrigation customers would save around 6.7%.
Single-family homes in the lowest usage tier can expect to see bills increase by 7.1%. Those in the average usage tier can expect bills to go up by about 5.9%.
Last year, the council approved across-the-board water rate increases of 14.7% in 2026 and 14.5% in 2027 to account for rising water purchasing costs and the rising cost of San Diego's under-construction water recycling infrastructure. The increase planned for 2027 would still take effect, but be adjusted to transition to the unitary rate structure.