Lawsuit Announced Against AAV Manufacturer In Service Members' Deaths
Attorneys representing the families of nine service members killed in an ocean-training accident near San Clemente Island last summer announced a lawsuit Thursday against the manufacturer of the amphibious-assault vehicle that sank with the men inside.
The lawsuit, to be filed on behalf of the families of eight Marines and one Navy sailor who died on July 30, 2020, alleges defects in the AAV's cargo hatch door left the servicemen trapped inside the vehicle with no way to get out.
Aleta Bath’s son, Evan A. Bath, was a 19-year-old Marine private on board the sunken AAV.
“He was my only son, my only child…. He was my whole world…” she said.
RELATED: Marine Relieves General Of Duties, Cites Last Year’s Fatal Seafaring Tank Sinking
The service members, ranging in age from 18 to 22, were taking part in a maritime training mission about 80 miles west of Encinitas and went down in water nearly 400 feet deep.
Seven members of the crew aboard the AAV were able to escape the sinking craft and survived.
The body of one Marine was recovered shortly after the accident. The naval Undersea Rescue Command recovered the other victims' remains from the sea floor eight days later.
Attorneys said the nine servicemembers spent 45 minutes trying to open the AAV's hatch door, but could not force it open or place the door in a locked and open position.
They said the vehicle's manufacturer, BAE Systems, has been aware of the problem for decades.
“I just want all of our boys to be safe going forward and I miss my kid, I would give anything to bring him back…” said Bath.
Annee Della Donna, one of the attorneys representing the families, said BAE "never bothered to fix it or notify the military. Instead, they've taken billions of dollars from U.S. taxpayers to build these death traps."
RELATED: Marines Open Another Probe Into Sunken Tank Blamed On Errors
When reached for comment on the suit, a BAE spokesperson issued the following statement: "We offer our deepest sympathies to the families impacted by this tragedy and we mourn the loss of the nine service members. We are not in a position to comment on ongoing litigation. The U.S. Marine Corps has conducted an investigation into this incident and we would ask you to contact them with any questions directly related to the incident."
A report issued earlier this year by the Marine Corps alleged poor maintenance of the AAVs and human errors regarding training played large roles in the accident.
Della Donna said many of the AAVs involved in the training mission were old and had reported maintenance issues, but that even with those problems, the men would have been able to escape the vehicle had the hatch door been operable.
The attorneys also said that despite negligence and human errors alleged on the part of military members in the Marine Corps investigation, the families are barred from suing the military due to what's called the Feres Doctrine, which prevents service members and their families from filing suit against the federal government for wrongful deaths or injuries sustained while serving.
RELATED: Human Errors, Mechanical Woes Caused Marine Tank Sinking
In addition to the lawsuit, attorneys and the families are working to get an emergency egress system established on AAVs, which would allow for hatch doors to immediately open, as well as a door designed to open inward to allow easier egress from the vehicle.
Della Donna said the families are also calling for the military to keep all AAVs from being used in the water until the necessary design changes are made.
A statement provided by the Marine Corps said it “is committed to identifying the issues that led to this tragedy and to preventing future occurrences. A comprehensive review of amphibious operations is underway, being conducted by senior Marine Corps and Navy personnel.
The investigation will look into the equipment, procedures, and training used in waterborne operations with AAVs.